Mendes Beyza, Gunes Bayir Ayse, Aksoy Ayse Semra, Toluk Ozlem
Department of Nutrition and Dietetics, Faculty of Health Sciences Bezmialem Vakif University Istanbul Türkiye.
Department of Food Hygiene and Technology, Faculty of Veterinary Medicine Kastamonu University Kastamonu Türkiye.
Food Sci Nutr. 2025 Jul 29;13(8):e70669. doi: 10.1002/fsn3.70669. eCollection 2025 Aug.
Malnutrition is preventable, and increasing investment in food and nutrient care for patients can save lives. A retrospective study evaluated the adequacy levels of the menus served in a hospital by making meal-based seasonal comparisons and examined the potential of these menus to pose a risk of malnutrition. In this context, the nutritional profile regarding energy, macro and micronutrients, and fiber was revealed. The results were compared with the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) and Türkiye Dietary Guideline-2022 (TDG-2022) recommendations. The nutrient profile of the menus was assessed by the Nutrient Rich Food NRF20.3 index (NRF20.3) and Limiting Nutrients 3 (LIM3) subscores. A one-year dataset obtained from a hospital menu includes three meals (breakfast, lunch, and dinner) with various menus (general, diabetic, and gluten-free) were examined, and the results of their nutrient profile were significantly different ( = 0.001). The NRF20.3 score for all menus and meals for a year was insignificant, while LIM3, the general menus for breakfast in spring, were higher than those of other menus ( = 0.001). The energy content of the general menus was between 1,621 and 1,663 kcal, which is high according to TDG-2022, instead of EFSA and FDA. Daily potassium, calcium, magnesium, and fiber of the menus were low according to TDG-2022 and EFSA, which is in accordance with including more meat and fewer vegetables, fruits, and dairy groups seasonally. Sodium and phosphorus in the menus were high. It was seen that the nutrient profile of the hospital menus examined in the study was not compatible with TDG-2022. The menus' high energy, fat, saturated fat, sodium, and low calcium and fiber content lead to imbalances in nutrient intake. This situation can lead to nutrient deficiencies in hospitalized individuals. However, when the amount of protein in the menus is considered, it is seen that hospital menus pose a risk of malnutrition for men while being sufficient for women.
营养不良是可以预防的,增加对患者食物和营养护理的投入可以挽救生命。一项回顾性研究通过按季节进行基于餐食的比较,评估了一家医院提供的菜单的充足程度,并研究了这些菜单导致营养不良风险的可能性。在此背景下,揭示了能量、宏量和微量营养素以及纤维方面的营养状况。将结果与美国食品药品监督管理局(FDA)、欧洲食品安全局(EFSA)和土耳其2022年膳食指南(TDG - 2022)的建议进行了比较。菜单的营养状况通过营养丰富食物NRF20.3指数(NRF20.3)和限制营养素3(LIM3)子评分进行评估。从一家医院菜单获取的一年数据集包括三餐(早餐、午餐和晚餐)以及各种菜单(普通、糖尿病和无麸质),并对其进行了检查,结果显示它们的营养状况存在显著差异(= 0.001)。一年中所有菜单和餐食的NRF20.3评分不显著,而春季早餐的普通菜单的LIM3高于其他菜单(= 0.001)。根据TDG - 2022,普通菜单的能量含量在1621至1663千卡之间,这高于EFSA和FDA的标准。根据TDG - 2022和EFSA,菜单中每日的钾、钙、镁和纤维含量较低,这与季节性地包含更多肉类、更少蔬菜、水果和奶制品组相符。菜单中的钠和磷含量较高。研究中检查的医院菜单的营养状况与TDG - 2022不相符。菜单中高能量、高脂肪、高饱和脂肪、高钠以及低钙和低纤维含量导致营养摄入不均衡。这种情况可能导致住院患者出现营养缺乏。然而,考虑到菜单中的蛋白质含量,发现医院菜单对男性构成营养不良风险,而对女性而言则足够。