Edan Vrinda, Brophy Lisa, Hamilton Bridget
Centre Mental Health Nursing, Alan Gilbert Building, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Victoria, Australia.
Department of Community and Clinical Health, School of Allied Health, Human Services and Sport, Room 321b Level 3 Health Sciences One, La Trobe University, Bundoora, Victoria, Australia.
Int J Ment Health Nurs. 2025 Jul;34(4):e70098. doi: 10.1111/inm.70098.
Advance statements are instruments under the Mental Health Act (2014) (Vic) (the Act) in Victoria, Australia that support advance care planning, should a person become a compulsory patient under the Act. Advance care planning supports consumers to have their values and preferences known to the service and other decision makers. Uptake of advance statements in mental health has been poor, and minimal literature is available that explores direct experiences of these instruments by consumers. Feminist Standpoint theory was used in this study as it centres the experience of the marginalised person within the study. This study comprised four in-depth interviews and a survey with 59 responses that explored consumers' direct experiences of using advance statements in Victoria. Results are consistent with past research identifying that many mental health advance statements were consenting documents, although some issues remained with locating the advance statement and identifying the most beneficial staff members to notify. Analysis of the interviews identified four main themes in people's experiences: not being read, working/not working, the use of advocacy and adjusting expectations. Consumers suggested how advance statements could be improved. Specific examples of advocacy by nurses were identified, and as the largest body of mental health workers, nurses have a key role in supporting consumers throughout their journey. Nurses are best placed to enact supported decision making, a key factor in advance care planning. With greater understanding of advance statements, and better resourcing of supported decision-making mechanisms, there is potential for advance statements to contribute to an improved experience for consumers in mental health services.
预先声明是澳大利亚维多利亚州《2014年精神健康法案》(维多利亚州)(该法案)规定的工具,在一个人根据该法案成为强制治疗患者的情况下,支持预先护理规划。预先护理规划有助于让服务机构和其他决策者了解消费者的价值观和偏好。精神健康领域预先声明的采用情况不佳,而且几乎没有文献探讨消费者对这些工具的直接体验。本研究采用了女性主义立场理论,因为它将被边缘化者的体验作为研究的核心。本研究包括四次深度访谈和一项有59份回复的调查,探讨了消费者在维多利亚州使用预先声明的直接体验。结果与过去的研究一致,即许多精神健康预先声明都是同意文件,尽管在查找预先声明以及确定最应通知的有益工作人员方面仍存在一些问题。对访谈的分析确定了人们体验中的四个主要主题:未被阅读、有效/无效、倡导的运用以及调整期望。消费者提出了如何改进预先声明的建议。确定了护士进行倡导的具体事例,而且作为精神健康工作者的最大群体,护士在消费者的整个就医过程中发挥着关键作用。护士最有能力实施支持性决策,这是预先护理规划的一个关键因素。随着对预先声明的更多了解以及支持性决策机制的更好资源配置,预先声明有可能为改善精神健康服务消费者的体验做出贡献。