Hannula Verneri, Lehtovirta Lari, Kourunen Linda, Sumanen Markku
Faculty of Medicine and Health Technology, Tampere University, Tampere, Finland.
Tampere University Hospital, The Wellbeing Services County of Pirkanmaa, Tampere, Finland.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2025 Jul 31;16:1297-1304. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S523181. eCollection 2025.
Learning in the clinical environment is crucial for students to enhance practical skills. However, due to the variability of clinical settings, providing consistent teaching and sufficient patient cases can be challenging. As a result, the perceived quality of rotations often varies. Previous studies have reported mixed findings on whether teaching quality or patient encounters influence students' perceptions of rotation quality or exam performance. Additionally, previous studies have often focused on structured teaching in clinical settings. We aimed to explore how students' evaluations of clinical teaching outside structured learning events during rotations impact the perceived achievement of learning goals.
We analysed student evaluations from paediatric and gynaecology rotations at Tampere University Medical School during the 2021-2022 academic year. Evaluations covered clinical teaching quality, opportunities to examine patients, and perform procedures. A linear regression model was used to assess the influence of these factors on the perceived achievement of learning goals, with the statement "I achieved the given learning goals" as the dependent variable.
A total of 140 students evaluated the paediatric and 142 the gynaecology rotations, providing 833 and 1188 evaluations, respectively. All questions received mean scores above 5 on a 7-point scale. The mean for achieving learning goals was 5.6 for paediatrics and 5.7 for gynaecology. All independent variables showed significant associations with the dependent variable, with "The use of time was meaningful" having the greatest impact.
Students generally reported successfully achieving their learning goals in both rotations. Notably, the perceived meaningful use of time had the greatest impact on the perceived achievement of learning outcomes.
在临床环境中学习对于学生提高实践技能至关重要。然而,由于临床环境的多样性,提供一致的教学和充足的患者案例可能具有挑战性。因此,轮转的感知质量往往各不相同。先前的研究报告了关于教学质量或患者接触是否会影响学生对轮转质量或考试成绩的看法的混合结果。此外,先前的研究通常侧重于临床环境中的结构化教学。我们旨在探讨学生在轮转期间对结构化学习活动之外的临床教学的评价如何影响对学习目标达成情况的感知。
我们分析了坦佩雷大学医学院2021 - 2022学年儿科和妇科轮转的学生评价。评价涵盖临床教学质量、检查患者和进行操作的机会。使用线性回归模型评估这些因素对学习目标达成情况感知的影响,将“我实现了既定的学习目标”这一陈述作为因变量。
共有140名学生对儿科轮转进行了评价,142名学生对妇科轮转进行了评价,分别提供了833份和1188份评价。所有问题在7分制量表上的平均得分均高于5分。儿科实现学习目标的平均分为5.6分,妇科为5.7分。所有自变量均与因变量显示出显著关联,其中“时间的利用是有意义的”影响最大。
学生普遍报告在两个轮转中都成功实现了学习目标。值得注意的是,时间利用的感知意义对学习成果达成情况的感知影响最大。