Watson Andrew
Global Systems Institute, University of Exeter, Exeter, UK.
Philos Trans R Soc Lond B Biol Sci. 2025 Aug 7;380(1931):20240105. doi: 10.1098/rstb.2024.0105.
The hard steps model is a 'toy' mathematical representation of evolution towards complex life on Earth or Earth-like planets. It assumes that, at the longest time scale, the rate of evolution towards increased complexity is governed by unlikely transitions that happen randomly and rarely. Applied to Earth, the model suggests a small number of such transitions in the pathway to 'intelligent observers'-humans. The transitions are usually envisaged as occurring instantaneously, but this ignores the reality that on Earth, the evolution of life and the planetary environment have been inextricably linked. The critical steps should be seen as initiating whole Earth-system transitions that take hundreds of millions of years to complete, as in the events that caused, and followed after, the Paleoproterozoic and Neoproterozoic glacial episodes. These were both caused by, and drivers of, evolutionary advances that were necessary for complex life to arise. I adapt the model to include such delays and show that it then suggests just two or three hard steps to humans. The model predicts that the search for biosignatures in exoplanet atmospheres may find planets with Archean-like atmospheres, but probably will not find the signature of a planet with a Proterozoic or modern Earth-like atmosphere.This article is part of the discussion meeting issue 'Chance and purpose in the evolution of biospheres'.
硬步骤模型是对地球上或类地行星上向复杂生命进化的一种“简化”数学表示。它假定,在最长的时间尺度上,向更高复杂性进化的速率受随机且罕见发生的不太可能的转变所支配。应用于地球时,该模型表明在通往“智能观察者”——人类的路径中有少量此类转变。这些转变通常被设想为瞬间发生,但这忽略了地球上生命进化与行星环境紧密相连的现实。关键步骤应被视为引发整个地球系统转变的起点,这些转变需要数亿年才能完成,就像古元古代和新元古代冰川事件所引发的以及后续发生的事件那样。这些事件既是复杂生命出现所必需的进化进步的起因,也是其驱动因素。我对该模型进行了调整,使其包含此类延迟,并表明调整后的模型表明通往人类只需两到三个硬步骤。该模型预测,在系外行星大气中寻找生物特征可能会发现具有太古宙样大气的行星,但可能找不到具有元古宙或现代地球样大气的行星的特征。本文是“生物圈进化中的机遇与目的”讨论会议题的一部分。