Kokorelias Kristina M, Sheikh Muhammad Harris, Naimi Maryam, Ho Bernice, Wong Edwin W, Brooks Stephanie G, Gandell Dov, Berger Arielle S
Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
University of British Columbia, British Columbia, Canada.
Can Med Educ J. 2025 Jul 2;16(3):33-45. doi: 10.36834/cmej.79033. eCollection 2025 Jul.
Professionalism is vital in medicine, yet gaps exist in its teaching within post-graduate medical education.
We developed an eight-session curriculum on professionalism for geriatrics residents at the University of Toronto. Topics included personal-professional identity, physician well-being, communication, and leadership, incorporating a focus on self-reflection throughout. We evaluated the curriculum in two ways: (1) we captured immediate reactions using standard evaluations with Likert-scale questions on teaching effectiveness. (2) Graduated residents participated in semi-structured interviews to assess deeper reactions and longer-term impacts on professional identity and practice. Interview transcripts were rigorously analyzed using thematic.
The teaching effectiveness scores averaged from 80 written evaluations were excellent: 4.45/5 (89%). We interviewed 12 of 22 eligible graduates (55%). Thematic analysis demonstrated that the curriculum impacted residents in three key thematic areas: (1) it led participants to understand their role as physicians in a more comprehensive way, while staying consistent with their personal values and strengths. (2) Communication skills training in particular equipped learners with important skills needed to enact their professional standards. (3) Through developing a supportive community and practicing mindful self-reflection, participants reported improvements in their well-being.
This paper demonstrates that professionalism can and should be integrated into the formal curriculum of post-graduate medical education. Key success factors in our study included a focus on fostering peer support and training in communication skills as a concrete method to actualize personal professional standards.
职业素养在医学领域至关重要,但在研究生医学教育中的教学仍存在差距。
我们为多伦多大学的老年医学住院医师开发了一门为期八节的职业素养课程。主题包括个人职业身份、医生福祉、沟通和领导力,始终注重自我反思。我们通过两种方式对该课程进行评估:(1)我们使用带有李克特量表问题的标准评估来获取即时反应,以评估教学效果。(2)毕业的住院医师参加半结构化访谈,以评估更深入的反应以及对职业身份和实践的长期影响。访谈记录使用主题分析法进行了严格分析。
从80份书面评估中得出的教学效果得分平均为优秀:4.45/5(89%)。我们对22名合格毕业生中的12名(55%)进行了访谈。主题分析表明,该课程在三个关键主题领域对住院医师产生了影响:(1)它使参与者以更全面的方式理解自己作为医生的角色,同时与个人价值观和优势保持一致。(2)特别是沟通技能培训为学习者提供了践行其职业标准所需的重要技能。(3)通过建立一个支持性的社区并进行正念自我反思,参与者报告称他们的福祉得到了改善。
本文表明,职业素养能够且应该融入研究生医学教育的正式课程中。我们研究中的关键成功因素包括注重培养同伴支持以及将沟通技能培训作为实现个人职业标准的具体方法。