Callaghan J J, Brand R A, Pedersen D R
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1985 Dec;67(9):1328-35.
In a retrospective study, we examined twenty-eight patients who had had an arthrodesis seventeen to fifty years previously (average, thirty-five years). Hip and knee ratings were obtained, as well as anteroposterior and flexion-extension radiographs of the lumbar spine and standing anteroposterior radiographs of the knees and hips. About 60 per cent of the patients had pain in the ipsilateral knee (average time to onset, twenty-three years after arthrodesis), and a similar percentage had back pain (average time to onset, twenty-five years after the operation). Pain in the contralateral hip occurred in approximately 25 per cent of the patients (average time to onset, twenty years after arthrodesis). Only one patient was unemployed due to disabling pain in the back or knee. Seventy per cent of the patients could walk more than one mile (1.6 kilometers), and a similar percentage could sit comfortably for at least two hours. Seventy-five per cent of the patients had anteroposterior laxity of the ipsilateral knee, and 80 per cent had mediolateral laxity. The patients whose hip was fused in some abduction more frequently had pain in the ipsilateral knee and the back, and they had greater degenerative changes in the ipsilateral knee than the patients whose hip was fused in adduction or in the neutral position. Six patients had undergone total hip arthroplasty for pain in the back or the ipsilateral knee, or both, and all had marked relief of back pain, while two of four had relief of pain in the knee. Two patients had a total knee arthroplasty for relief of pain in the ipsilateral knee.
在一项回顾性研究中,我们检查了28例患者,他们在17至50年前(平均35年)接受了关节融合术。获得了髋关节和膝关节评分,以及腰椎的前后位和屈伸位X线片,以及膝关节和髋关节的站立前后位X线片。约60%的患者同侧膝关节疼痛(平均发病时间为关节融合术后23年),类似比例的患者有背痛(平均发病时间为手术后25年)。对侧髋关节疼痛发生在约25%的患者中(平均发病时间为关节融合术后20年)。只有1例患者因背部或膝关节疼痛致残而失业。70%的患者能行走超过1英里(1.6公里),类似比例的患者能舒适地坐至少2小时。75%的患者同侧膝关节有前后向松弛,80%有内外侧松弛。髋关节在一定外展角度融合的患者比髋关节在内收位或中立位融合的患者更常出现同侧膝关节和背部疼痛,且同侧膝关节的退行性改变更严重。6例患者因背部或同侧膝关节疼痛或两者皆有而接受了全髋关节置换术,所有患者的背痛均明显缓解,而4例中有2例膝关节疼痛缓解。2例患者接受了全膝关节置换术以缓解同侧膝关节疼痛。