Liu Weijian, Wang Zhonghe, Zhang Zhizeng, Zhang Zhengyu, Jia Yongfu, Li Zhun
School of Intelligent Construction and Architectural Engineering, Zhongyuan University of Technology, Zhengzhou, 450007, China.
School of Earth Sciences and Engineering, North China University of Water Resources and Hydropower, Zhengzhou, 450045, China.
Sci Rep. 2025 Aug 11;15(1):29383. doi: 10.1038/s41598-025-15139-w.
This study investigates the behavior of retaining structures and the settlement of external surfaces in deep foundation pits located in areas characterized by muddy soft soil. The research evaluates the efficacy of two constitutive models-the traditional Mohr-Coulomb model and the modified Cambridge model-during the simulation of foundation pit excavation. By analyzing actual monitoring data collected from the site, the study identifies patterns in the settlement and deformation of both the retaining structure and the surface. Subsequently, the excavation process of the foundation pit is simulated using FLAC3D 6.0 software, employing both the Mohr-Coulomb and modified Cambridge models. A comparative analysis is conducted between the simulation results and the field monitoring data to assess the performance of the two models.The findings indicate that the horizontal displacement and surface settlement curves of the retaining structure in muddy soft soil exhibit cantilever behavior. The maximum horizontal displacement occurs near the excavation face, while the peak surface settlement is observed 15 m from the foundation pit, remaining within the established early warning thresholds. Although both models demonstrate a similar trend in the simulated displacement curves compared to the actual deformation curves, there are notable differences in accuracy. Specifically, the modified Cambridge model generally exhibits a lower error rate in simulating the horizontal displacement of the retaining structure compared to the traditional Mohr-Coulomb model. Furthermore, the modified Cambridge model provides a closer approximation to the measured values for surface settlement outside the foundation pit.In conclusion, for deep foundation pits associated with subway construction that utilize concrete support and underground continuous walls in muddy soft soil regions, the horizontal displacement and surface settlement curves of the retaining structure display cantilever characteristics. The modified Cambridge model demonstrates superior simulation performance, yielding results that are more closely aligned with actual monitoring data.
本研究调查了位于淤泥质软土地区的深基坑中支护结构的行为以及外表面的沉降情况。该研究评估了两种本构模型——传统的摩尔-库仑模型和修正的剑桥模型——在基坑开挖模拟过程中的有效性。通过分析从现场收集的实际监测数据,该研究确定了支护结构和地表沉降及变形的模式。随后,使用FLAC3D 6.0软件,采用摩尔-库仑模型和修正的剑桥模型对基坑开挖过程进行了模拟。对模拟结果与现场监测数据进行了对比分析,以评估这两种模型的性能。研究结果表明,淤泥质软土中支护结构的水平位移和地表沉降曲线呈现出悬臂梁行为。最大水平位移出现在开挖面附近,而地表沉降峰值在距基坑15米处观测到,仍在既定的预警阈值范围内。虽然与实际变形曲线相比,两种模型在模拟位移曲线上都呈现出相似的趋势,但在精度上存在显著差异。具体而言,与传统的摩尔-库仑模型相比,修正的剑桥模型在模拟支护结构的水平位移时,通常显示出较低的误差率。此外,修正的剑桥模型对基坑外地表沉降的测量值提供了更接近的近似值。总之,对于在淤泥质软土地区采用混凝土支撑和地下连续墙的地铁建设相关深基坑,支护结构的水平位移和地表沉降曲线呈现出悬臂梁特征。修正的剑桥模型表现出卓越的模拟性能,其结果与实际监测数据更为接近。