Thomas Beatrice C, Tiarks Georgina C, Al-Eyd Ghaith, Rajput Vijay
Department of Pediatrics, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, Cincinnati, USA.
Department of Internal Medicine, The George Washington University School of Medicine and Health Sciences, Washington, D.C., USA.
Cureus. 2025 Jul 12;17(7):e87784. doi: 10.7759/cureus.87784. eCollection 2025 Jul.
Lectures have been the cornerstone of education for centuries. As society has modernized, science has elucidated multiple key aspects required for effective learning and retention of knowledge. In the last several decades, undergraduate medical education (UME) has changed with the incorporation of mandatory active small group learning and self-directed study in pre-clerkship education. Lectures have become non-mandatory school activities with poor attendance by students and a sore subject by the UME community. In addition, the use of standardized national exams throughout medical school has paved the way for the use of third-party commercial resources focused on "high-yield" materials that are widely supported by students and schools. Consequently, medical students have begun to forego traditional didactics in favor of commercial resources and self-study time. Hence, there is a growing frustration among faculty over poor attendance and engagement. However, lectures and seminars have continued to thrive in clerkships, graduate medical education, and continuing medical education despite the downfall in pre-clerkship education. Lectures in pre-clerkship education may need to be restructured and delivered in a style that fits the growing educational needs of advanced adult learners. This article critically reviews the historical role and current status of lecture in UME, while providing recommendations for future actionable changes.
几个世纪以来,讲座一直是教育的基石。随着社会的现代化,科学已经阐明了有效学习和知识保留所需的多个关键方面。在过去几十年里,本科医学教育(UME)发生了变化,在临床实习前的教育中纳入了强制性的小组主动学习和自主学习。讲座已成为非强制性的学校活动,学生出勤率低,也是UME社区的一个敏感话题。此外,在整个医学院使用标准化的国家考试,为使用专注于“高收益”材料的第三方商业资源铺平了道路,这些资源得到了学生和学校的广泛支持。因此,医学生开始放弃传统教学方式,转而青睐商业资源和自学时间。因此,教师们对出勤率低和参与度低的情况越来越感到沮丧。然而,尽管临床实习前教育有所衰落,但讲座和研讨会在临床实习、毕业后医学教育和继续医学教育中仍继续蓬勃发展。临床实习前教育中的讲座可能需要进行重组,并以适合成年高级学习者不断增长的教育需求的方式进行授课。本文批判性地回顾了讲座在UME中的历史作用和现状,同时为未来可行的变革提供了建议。