Shih Rong-Fang, Pai Hsiang-Chu
Department of Nursing, Jian-Shin Nursing Home, Taiwan, ROC.
Department of Nursing, Chung-Shan Medical University Hospital, Chung-Shan Medical University, Taichung, Taiwan, ROC.
Nurs Health Sci. 2025 Sep;27(3):e70210. doi: 10.1111/nhs.70210.
This study aims to compare the differences in professional environment, job characteristics, and feelings of powerlessness between nurses and nurse aides (NAs) in residential long-term care institutions, and to analyze the predictors of powerlessness. This study employed a comparative and correlational design, utilizing convenience sampling. Participants were recruited from 24 residential long-term care institutions in central Taiwan between April 2023 and March 2024. The research tools included a Practice Environment Survey Scale, a Work Design Questionnaire, and a Powerlessness Scale. A total of 338 participants (156 nurses and 182 NAs) took part in this study. Both nurses and NAs reported moderate to low levels of powerlessness, with average scores of 42.18 and 37.07, respectively. However, nurses experienced more powerlessness than NAs (t = 3.046, p = 0.003). Hierarchical regression analysis indicated that professional environment (β = -0.381, p < 0.01) and job characteristics (β = -0.285, p = 0.005) were significant predictors of powerlessness among nurses, explaining 41.7% of the variance. In contrast, the only predictor of powerlessness for NAs was the professional environment (β = -0.695, p < 0.001), which explained 42.4% of the variance.
本研究旨在比较长期照护机构中护士与护理员在专业环境、工作特征及无助感方面的差异,并分析无助感的预测因素。本研究采用比较和相关性设计,运用便利抽样法。研究对象于2023年4月至2024年3月期间从台湾中部的24家长期照护机构招募。研究工具包括实践环境调查量表、工作设计问卷和无助感量表。共有338名参与者(156名护士和182名护理员)参与了本研究。护士和护理员报告的无助感水平均为中度至低度,平均得分分别为42.18和37.07。然而,护士比护理员经历了更多的无助感(t = 3.046,p = 0.003)。分层回归分析表明,专业环境(β = -0.381,p < 0.01)和工作特征(β = -0.285,p = 0.005)是护士无助感的显著预测因素,解释了41.7%的变异。相比之下,护理员无助感的唯一预测因素是专业环境(β = -0.695,p < 0.001),解释了42.4%的变异。