Jensen R K, Heilmann S, Thomsen J N, Hansen J K, Arnbjerg O, Bell C, Jensen T S
Department of Sports Science and Clinical Biomechanics, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark.
Chiropractic Knowledge Hub, Odense, Denmark.
Chiropr Man Therap. 2025 Aug 21;33(1):33. doi: 10.1186/s12998-025-00594-z.
There appears to be a substantial variation in the use of radiographs in chiropractic clinics, but the reasons for this variation are not well understood. This study examined the use of radiography over a one-year period in Danish chiropractic clinics and explored its associations with clinic- and chiropractor-level characteristics.
Data on the number of unique patients consulting a chiropractor and those receiving radiography between 1 January 2022 and 31 December 2022 were obtained from a Danish national registry. Information on clinics including the number of chiropractors, geographical region, multidisciplinary status, and types of other healthcare professionals employed, as well as chiropractor characteristics (age, gender, seniority, and country of education) was collected from clinic websites and a national register of Danish healthcare professionals. The proportion of patients undergoing radiography was calculated for each clinic. Associations with clinic and chiropractic characteristics were tested using chi-square or t-tests, as appropriate. Characteristics were also compared between clinics with and without in-house radiographic imaging facilities.
A total of 237 chiropractic clinics and 657 chiropractors were included. The mean age of chiropractors was 47 years (SD 12.8), 53% were women and 61.8% were educated in Denmark. Clinics with radiographic facilities (n = 161, 68%) tended to be larger and more likely to be multidisciplinary than clinics without (n = 76, 32%). Among clinics with radiographic facilities, the proportion of patients receiving radiography was 9.5% (95% CI 8.4-10.6%), ranging from 0 to 39%. No associations were found between radiography use in clinics with in-house radiographic facilities and clinic or chiropractic characteristics. In clinics without radiographic facilities, only 1.1% of patients were referred for radiography via chiropractic service codes, although this is likely an underestimation, as referrals to public hospitals were not captured.
Although considerable variation in radiography use was observed across Danish chiropractic clinics with radiographic facilities, this was not explained by measured clinic or chiropractic characteristics. The true extent of radiography use in clinics without in-house facilities remains uncertain. Further research into clinical decision-making is needed to support evidence-based, transparent and consistent practice, potentially using qualitative methods to better understand the reasons behind the observed variation.
脊椎按摩疗法诊所中X光片的使用情况似乎存在很大差异,但这种差异的原因尚不清楚。本研究调查了丹麦脊椎按摩疗法诊所在一年时间内X光片的使用情况,并探讨了其与诊所及脊椎按摩师层面特征的关联。
从丹麦国家登记处获取了2022年1月1日至2022年12月31日期间咨询脊椎按摩师的独特患者数量以及接受X光检查的患者数量的数据。从诊所网站和丹麦医疗保健专业人员国家登记处收集了有关诊所的信息,包括脊椎按摩师数量、地理区域、多学科状况以及所雇佣的其他医疗保健专业人员类型,以及脊椎按摩师的特征(年龄、性别、资历和教育国家)。计算每个诊所接受X光检查的患者比例。根据情况,使用卡方检验或t检验来测试与诊所和脊椎按摩特征的关联。还比较了有和没有内部X光成像设施的诊所之间的特征。
共纳入237家脊椎按摩疗法诊所和657名脊椎按摩师。脊椎按摩师的平均年龄为47岁(标准差12.8),53%为女性,61.8%在丹麦接受教育。拥有X光设施的诊所(n = 161,68%)往往比没有X光设施的诊所(n = 76,32%)规模更大,且更有可能是多学科诊所。在拥有X光设施的诊所中,接受X光检查的患者比例为9.5%(95%置信区间8.4 - 10.6%),范围从0到39%。在拥有内部X光设施的诊所中,X光片的使用与诊所或脊椎按摩特征之间未发现关联。在没有X光设施的诊所中,只有1.1%的患者通过脊椎按摩服务代码被转诊进行X光检查,不过这可能被低估了,因为未涵盖转至公立医院的情况。
尽管在拥有X光设施的丹麦脊椎按摩疗法诊所中观察到X光片使用存在很大差异,但这并不能通过所测量的诊所或脊椎按摩特征来解释。没有内部设施的诊所中X光片使用的真实程度仍不确定。需要进一步研究临床决策,以支持基于证据、透明且一致的实践,可能需要使用定性方法来更好地理解所观察到的差异背后的原因。