Lima Luciana Dias de, Dias Henrique Sant'Anna, Mendonça Fernanda de Freitas, Silva André Schimidt da, Carvalho Brígida Gimenez, Martins Caroline Pagani, Pereira Adelyne Maria Mendes
Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública Sergio Arouca, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Rio de Janeiro, Brasil.
Universidade Estadual de Londrina, Londrina, Brasil.
Cad Saude Publica. 2025 Aug 22;41(8):e00206924. doi: 10.1590/0102-311XPT206924. eCollection 2025.
This article analyzes the implementation of changes in national primary health care (PHC) policies in Brazil, and their repercussions in the Metropolitan Health Region I of Rio de Janeiro and in the Northern MacroRregion of Paraná between 2017 and 2022. This multicenter study adopts a comparative approach and mixed methods to identify similarities and differences between cases in three analytical axes: profile, institutional positioning, and conceptions about PHC; organizational decisions related to the work process; coverage and composition of teams. A total of 44 interviews were conducted with managers in 14 selected municipalities and secondary data were analyzed. Higher degrees in health, introduction to Public Health and short time in office, due to municipal elections, were common characteristics of the interviewees. There was convergence in the conceptions of PHC and the Family Health Strategy, as well as tensions and favorable positions for the Prevent Brazil Program, which encouraged organizational changes in the registration of the population and in the fulfillment of goals. A diverse set of strategies for monitoring, evaluation and maintenance of programs and actions was identified, as well as a reduction in the number of community health agents per team and an increase in the number of teams per basic health unit. Despite the predominance of family health teams, there were differences between the proportion of the registered population and the number of teams in the Family Health Support Center. The analysis suggests that the implementation of PHC guidelines and their repercussions are influenced by complex and interdependent factors, such as municipal capacities, intergovernmental relations, and state action within the regional context.
本文分析了巴西国家初级卫生保健(PHC)政策变化的实施情况,以及这些变化在2017年至2022年期间对里约热内卢第一大城市卫生区和巴拉那州北部宏观区域的影响。这项多中心研究采用比较方法和混合方法,从三个分析维度确定案例之间的异同:概况、机构定位以及对初级卫生保健的概念理解;与工作流程相关的组织决策;团队的覆盖范围和组成。研究共对14个选定市的管理人员进行了44次访谈,并对二手数据进行了分析。受访者的共同特征包括拥有卫生领域的高等学位、接受过公共卫生入门培训以及因市政选举而任职时间较短。在初级卫生保健和家庭健康战略的概念理解上存在趋同,同时对于“预防巴西”计划也存在紧张关系和有利立场,该计划推动了人口登记和目标实现方面的组织变革。研究确定了一系列用于监测、评估和维持项目及行动的不同策略,以及每个团队中社区卫生工作者数量的减少和每个基本卫生单位中团队数量的增加。尽管家庭健康团队占主导地位,但家庭健康支持中心的登记人口比例与团队数量之间存在差异。分析表明,初级卫生保健指南的实施及其影响受到复杂且相互依存的因素影响,如市政能力、政府间关系以及区域背景下的国家行动。