Abbas Rizwan, Bracke Piet, Delaruelle Katrijn
Health and Demographic Research (HeDeRa), Department of Sociology, Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium.
Department of Sociology, Ghazi University Dera Ghazi Khan, Dera Ghazi Khan, Punjab, Pakistan.
BMC Psychol. 2025 Aug 27;13(1):976. doi: 10.1186/s40359-025-03337-0.
Evidence has shown that the use of mental health services is less common among Pakistani adolescents and young adults compared to their peers in Western and English-speaking countries, despite a higher prevalence of mental health issues. This disparity suggests the presence of cultural and societal stigma affecting help-seeking behaviors. Our study aims to explore the prevalent forms of mental health causal attributions and help-seeking care recommendations in this population. Additionally, we investigated how these causal attributions influence help-seeking care recommendations and in what way perceived stigmatizing attitudes play a mediating role.
The self-administered cross-sectional study included 1,328 college undergraduates aged 15-24 years in Layyah, Pakistan. Causal attributions were measured using 28 items distributed into five groups. Help-seeking care recommendations were assessed on a 20-item scale divided into four groups. Public stigmatizing attitudes were measured using items from the Eurobarometer 64.4 survey. The effect of causal attributions on help-seeking care recommendations was analyzed through multiple linear regression. Finally, we estimated the mediation effect of perceived public stigmatizing attitudes using PROCESS v4.0 macros for SPSS.
More than half (51.7%) of the adolescents demonstrated stereotypical attitudes, and one in four underestimated the severeness of the complaints. Psychosocial causes were the most prevalent mental health attribution, identified in 98% of the responses. Similarly, self-care (97.8%) and informal social support (97.7%) were the most common help-seeking care recommendations. Our findings revealed that labeling mental health issues as having religious and supernatural causes relates to formal social support from religious healers [β = 0.23, 95% CI 0.17-0.29, p < 0.001], and participants who attributed psychosocial causes also recommended support from religious healers [β = 0.19, 95% CI 0.10-0.27, p < 0.001]. The mediation model indicated an indirect association consistent with a partial mediating role of perceived public stereotypical attitudes, as adolescents and young adults attributing psychosocial causes to mental health were more likely to recommend formal social support from religious healers (β = 0.31, p ≤ 0.001) and informal social support (β = 0.29, p ≤ 0.001).
The study confirmed that attributing causes to mental health strongly relate to care recommendation patterns. Furthermore, the mediating role of perceived public stereotypical attitudes was recognized in determining the relationship between mental health causal attribution and help-seeking care recommendations.
有证据表明,与西方和英语国家的同龄人相比,巴基斯坦青少年和年轻人使用心理健康服务的情况较少,尽管心理健康问题的患病率较高。这种差异表明存在影响求助行为的文化和社会污名。我们的研究旨在探讨该人群中常见的心理健康因果归因形式和求助护理建议。此外,我们调查了这些因果归因如何影响求助护理建议,以及感知到的污名化态度以何种方式发挥中介作用。
这项自填式横断面研究纳入了巴基斯坦莱雅的1328名15 - 24岁的大学生。使用分为五组的28个项目来测量因果归因。求助护理建议通过分为四组的20项量表进行评估。使用欧洲晴雨表64.4调查中的项目来测量公众污名化态度。通过多元线性回归分析因果归因对求助护理建议的影响。最后,我们使用SPSS的PROCESS v4.0宏程序估计感知到的公众污名化态度的中介效应。
超过一半(51.7%)的青少年表现出刻板态度,四分之一的人低估了症状的严重程度。心理社会原因是最常见的心理健康归因,在98%的回答中被提及。同样,自我护理(97.8%)和非正式社会支持(97.7%)是最常见的求助护理建议。我们的研究结果表明,将心理健康问题归因于宗教和超自然原因与宗教治疗师的正式社会支持有关[β = 0.23,95%可信区间0.17 - 0.29,p < 0.001],将心理社会原因归因的参与者也建议寻求宗教治疗师的支持[β = 0.19,95%可信区间0.10 - 0.27,p < 0.001]。中介模型表明存在间接关联,这与感知到的公众刻板态度的部分中介作用一致,因为将心理社会原因归因于心理健康的青少年和年轻人更有可能建议寻求宗教治疗师的正式社会支持(β = 0.31,p ≤ 0.001)和非正式社会支持(β = 0.29,p ≤ 0.001)。
该研究证实,心理健康的因果归因与护理建议模式密切相关。此外,在确定心理健康因果归因与求助护理建议之间的关系时,感知到的公众刻板态度的中介作用得到了认可。