Newman Rhiannon, Rashid Mohammed A
School of Clinical Medicine, University of Cambridge, Cambridge Biomedical Campus, Cambridge, UK.
London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, UK.
Clin Teach. 2025 Oct;22(5):e70188. doi: 10.1111/tct.70188.
Medical migration describes the movement of doctors across national boundaries and has historically followed a gradient from low- and middle-income countries (LMIC) to high-income countries (HIC), typically for training and income opportunities. Whilst the challenges of being an international medical graduate (IMG) are well-documented, not all doctors stay in their host country, and comparatively little is known about the experiences of those who return to their home country. Qualitative studies examining the experiences of IMGs returning to home countries were identified through database (Ovid, ProQuest, Medline, Scopus and EBSCOhost) and manual searching and were synthesised following a meta-ethnographic approach. A total of seven studies were included in the synthesis, published between 1975 and 2019, charting the experiences of 134 doctors returning to Africa, South America, Europe, Asia or Oceania. A total of 10 third-order constructs were identified that were developed into overarching third-order constructs: reflections on personal development, social and cultural connection to home countries and challenges associated with professional reintegration. Return migration in doctors has received little attention, indicating a need for further research in this area. The commonality of experiences in this review suggests that whilst family trumps finances in reasons to return, disillusionment with state healthcare systems in home countries encourages a drive to private practice and the wasted opportunity for valuable knowledge transfer. These findings can enable medical educators to better support IMGs considering and experiencing return migration, and inform policymakers seeking to optimise conditions for return migration as part of medical workforce planning.
医学人才迁移描述了医生跨越国界的流动,历史上一直呈现出从低收入和中等收入国家(LMIC)流向高收入国家(HIC)的趋势,通常是为了获得培训和收入机会。虽然国际医学毕业生(IMG)所面临的挑战已有充分记录,但并非所有医生都留在东道国,而对于那些回国医生的经历,人们了解得相对较少。通过数据库(Ovid、ProQuest、Medline、Scopus和EBSCOhost)以及手动检索,确定了关于回国国际医学毕业生经历的定性研究,并采用元民族志方法进行综合分析。该综合分析共纳入了七项研究,这些研究发表于1975年至2019年之间,记录了134名医生返回非洲、南美洲、欧洲、亚洲或大洋洲的经历。总共确定了10个三阶构建体,并将其发展为总体三阶构建体:对个人发展的反思、与祖国的社会文化联系以及与职业重新融入相关的挑战。医生的回国迁移很少受到关注,这表明该领域需要进一步研究。本综述中经历的共性表明,虽然回国原因中家庭因素胜过经济因素,但对祖国国家医疗体系的失望促使人们转向私人执业,也造成了宝贵知识转移的机会浪费。这些发现可以使医学教育工作者更好地支持考虑回国迁移和正在经历回国迁移的国际医学毕业生,并为寻求优化回国迁移条件以作为医疗劳动力规划一部分的政策制定者提供参考。