对于3b型急性腘绳肌复合体损伤,径向体外冲击波疗法联合特定康复方案(rESWT+RP)比假体外冲击波疗法联合康复方案更有效:一项随机对照试验。
Radial ESWT combined with a specific rehabilitation program (rESWT+RP) is more effective than sham rESWT+RP for acute hamstring muscle complex injury type 3b: a randomized, controlled trial.
作者信息
Crupnik Javier, Silveti Santiago, Wajnstein Natalia, Rolon Alejandro, Wuerfel Tobias, Stiller Peter, Morral Antoni, Furia John P, Maffulli Nicola, Schmitz Christoph
机构信息
KinEf Sports Physiotherapy Center, Av. Cabildo 808 2°C, C1026 Cdad. Autónoma de Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Physiotherapy School Medicine and Health Sciences Faculty, Universidad Abierta Interamericana, Chacabuco 90, C1069 Cdad. Autónoma de Buenos Aires, Argentina.
出版信息
Br Med Bull. 2025 Sep 1;155(1). doi: 10.1093/bmb/ldaf009.
INTRODUCTION
Acute type 3b injuries of the hamstring muscle complex (HMC) are prevalent in sports, often lead to prolonged recovery, and demonstrate a high recurrence. Conservative rehabilitation is standard, and adjunct therapies such as radial extracorporeal shock wave therapy (rESWT) may offer additional benefits.
SOURCES OF DATA
This randomized controlled trial, with blinding of patients and assessors, included 36 semi-professional athletes with ultrasound-confirmed acute type 3b HMC injuries. Participants received either real or sham rESWT in combination with an 8-week structured rehabilitation program. The primary outcome was time to return to sport; secondary outcomes included post-treatment muscle strength, patient satisfaction, and re-injury rate.
AREAS OF AGREEMENT
Progressive rehabilitation is effective for muscle injuries. rESWT is a safe, non-invasive modality with high therapeutic potential in musculoskeletal conditions.
AREAS OF CONTROVERSY
Questions remain regarding the ideal rESWT protocol for acute muscle injuries, including optimal dosing, frequency, and timing relative to injury onset.
GROWING POINTS
The addition of rESWT resulted in a statistically significant reduction in return-to-sport time [25.4 ± 3.5 (mean ± SD) days with rESWT vs 28.3 ± 4.5 days with sham rESWT; P = .037]. In elite and semi-professional athletes, even modest reductions in downtime can carry meaningful performance and economic benefits. Furthermore, only the rESWT group avoided strength deficits in the previously injured leg, suggesting improved functional recovery.
AREAS TIMELY FOR DEVELOPING RESEARCH
Future studies should explore the comparative effectiveness of individualized versus standardized rESWT protocols and investigate its broader applicability across sports disciplines and levels of play.
引言
腘绳肌复合体(HMC)急性3b型损伤在体育运动中很常见,常导致恢复时间延长,且复发率高。保守康复是标准治疗方法,而诸如放射状体外冲击波疗法(rESWT)等辅助疗法可能会带来额外益处。
数据来源
这项随机对照试验对患者和评估者进行了盲法处理,纳入了36名经超声确诊为急性3b型HMC损伤的半职业运动员。参与者接受了真正的或假的rESWT,并结合为期8周的结构化康复计划。主要结局是恢复运动的时间;次要结局包括治疗后的肌肉力量、患者满意度和再损伤率。
共识领域
渐进性康复对肌肉损伤有效。rESWT是一种安全、非侵入性的治疗方式,在肌肉骨骼疾病方面具有很高的治疗潜力。
争议领域
关于急性肌肉损伤的理想rESWT方案,包括最佳剂量、频率以及相对于损伤发生时间的治疗时机等问题仍然存在。
发展要点
添加rESWT导致恢复运动时间在统计学上显著缩短[rESWT组为25.4±3.5(均值±标准差)天,假rESWT组为28.3±4.5天;P = 0.037]。在精英和半职业运动员中,即使是恢复时间的适度缩短也能带来有意义的运动表现和经济效益。此外,只有rESWT组避免了受伤腿部的力量不足,表明功能恢复得到改善。
适合开展研究的领域
未来的研究应探索个体化与标准化rESWT方案的比较效果,并调查其在不同体育项目和比赛水平中的更广泛适用性。