Wiens John J, Saban Kristen E
Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology, University of Arizona, Tucson, Arizona, United States of America.
Department of Organismic and Evolutionary Biology, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, United States of America.
PLoS Biol. 2025 Sep 4;23(9):e3003356. doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.3003356. eCollection 2025 Sep.
An important aspect of the current extinction crisis is the loss of distinct clades (e.g., genera). A recent study suggested that there is rapidly accelerating extinction of genera (and other higher taxa), indicating a current mass extinction event that endangers human survival. However, that study was based only on land vertebrates, which include only about half of vertebrates and <2% of living species. Here, we examine the recent extinction (last 500 years) of higher taxa across living organisms. We find that 102 genera have gone extinct (90 animals, 12 plants), along with 10 families and two orders. Yet, the majority of these genus-level extinctions were among mammals and birds, as were all extinctions of families and orders. There were very few extinctions among the thousands of genera of ray-finned fishes (n = 4; 0.08%), squamate reptiles (n = 2; 0.17%), and amphibians (n = 1; 0.18%). Documented extinctions were also rare among the thousands of assessed genera of arthropods (n = 11; 0.32%) and plants (n = 12; 0.17%), which together encompass most known species. Most extinct genera were monotypic (~80%), and most were island endemics (76%). Moreover, despite the claim that extinctions of higher taxa are rapidly accelerating, the highest rates of genus-level extinctions occurred more than 100 years ago, and have declined subsequently. Overall, the recent extinctions of higher taxa are not as dire as previously suggested.
当前灭绝危机的一个重要方面是独特进化枝(如属)的丧失。最近一项研究表明,属(以及其他更高分类单元)的灭绝正在迅速加速,这表明当前正发生一场危及人类生存的大灭绝事件。然而,该研究仅基于陆地脊椎动物,而陆地脊椎动物仅约占脊椎动物的一半,占现存物种的比例不到2%。在此,我们研究了整个生物界最近(过去500年)更高分类单元的灭绝情况。我们发现有102个属已经灭绝(90个动物属,12个植物属),还有10个科和2个目。然而,这些属级灭绝事件大多发生在哺乳动物和鸟类中,科和目的灭绝也都是如此。在数千个辐鳍鱼属中,灭绝的很少(n = 4;0.08%),有鳞目爬行动物中灭绝的也很少(n = 2;0.17%),两栖动物中同样如此(n = 1;0.18%)。在数千个已评估的节肢动物属(n = 11;0.32%)和植物属(n = 12;0.17%)中,有记录的灭绝情况也很罕见,而节肢动物和植物共同涵盖了大多数已知物种。大多数灭绝的属是单型的(约80%),并且大多数是岛屿特有种(76%)。此外,尽管有人声称更高分类单元的灭绝正在迅速加速,但属级灭绝的最高速率出现在100多年前,随后已经下降。总体而言,最近更高分类单元的灭绝情况并不像之前所认为的那么严峻。