Garg Joshua, McLelland Thomas
Medical Education and Simulation, Queen Elizabeth Hospital Birmingham, Birmingham, GBR.
Medical Education and Simulation, Sandwell and West Birmingham Hospitals NHS Trust, Birmingham, GBR.
Cureus. 2025 Aug 6;17(8):e89521. doi: 10.7759/cureus.89521. eCollection 2025 Aug.
Simulation is a widely used educational tool for both undergraduate and postgraduate medical education. There are different levels of simulation fidelity; low fidelity uses simplistic models but is often cost/time effective, whereas high fidelity tends to bring more realism but is resource-intensive. In undergraduate medical training, simulation is often used for students in their final year of medical school prior to qualifying as a doctor, and therefore, the literature is limited with regard to students in their earlier years of training. The aim of this project was to create cost/resource-effective, low-fidelity simulation training sessions for more junior medical students to help them consolidate skills learnt in isolation, in turn facilitating higher levels of critical thinking.
We developed low-fidelity simulation sessions for third-year (first year clinical) medical students. These comprised clinical scenarios that would encourage students to apply skills that were previously taught or assessed in isolation, to form a holistic clinical assessment of a patient. Students were given a pre- and post-session questionnaire to help ascertain the usefulness of the sessions.
Thirty-two students took part in the simulation sessions. Questionnaires were used to ascertain their level of confidence in the full assessment of a patient. Their pre- and post-session feedback was compared, and the subjective scores were 4.09/10 and 8.25/10, respectively (p<0.05). Qualitative feedback suggested that the students enjoyed the clinically adjacent nature of the scenarios and felt that they were able to consolidate the knowledge they had obtained in pre-clinical years.
DISCUSSION/CONCLUSIONS: We demonstrated that students in earlier years of training can benefit from simulation teaching. Running the sessions was light on resources and an effective tool for students to consolidate skills and apply higher levels of thinking, preparing them for future years of training.
模拟是一种广泛应用于本科和研究生医学教育的教学工具。模拟逼真度有不同级别;低逼真度使用简单模型,但通常具有成本效益/时间效益,而高逼真度往往带来更高的真实感,但资源密集。在本科医学培训中,模拟通常用于医学院最后一年即将获得医生资格的学生,因此,关于早期培训阶段学生的文献有限。本项目的目的是为低年级医学生创建具有成本效益/资源效益的低逼真度模拟培训课程,以帮助他们巩固孤立学习的技能,进而促进更高水平的批判性思维。
我们为三年级(临床第一年)医学生开发了低逼真度模拟课程。这些课程包含临床场景,鼓励学生应用之前单独教授或评估过的技能,对患者进行全面的临床评估。学生在课程前后分别填写问卷,以帮助确定课程的实用性。
32名学生参加了模拟课程。通过问卷确定他们对全面评估患者的信心水平。比较他们在课程前后的反馈,主观评分分别为4.09/10和8.25/10(p<0.05)。定性反馈表明,学生喜欢这些场景贴近临床的性质,并认为他们能够巩固在临床前几年学到的知识。
讨论/结论:我们证明了早期培训阶段的学生可以从模拟教学中受益。开展这些课程资源需求少,是学生巩固技能和应用更高层次思维的有效工具,为他们未来几年的培训做好准备。