Lai Keyun, Chen Xiao, He Liyun, Liu Qi, Lai Changsheng, Bai Yang, Zhang Ye, Wang Kaiyue, Wang Fangzhao, He Shuai, Wang Guangjun
Xi'an Traditional Chinese Medicine Encephalopathy Hospital Affiliated to Shaanxi University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Xi'an, China.
Institute of Clinical Basic Medicine of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Chinese Academy of Chinese Medical Sciences, Beijing, China.
Neurotrauma Rep. 2025 Aug 27;6(1):720-731. doi: 10.1177/2689288X251369274. eCollection 2025.
Accurate differentiation between persistent vegetative state (PVS) and minimally conscious state and estimation of recovery likelihood in patients in PVS are crucial. This study analyzed electroencephalography (EEG) metrics to investigate their relationship with consciousness improvements in patients in PVS and developed a machine learning prediction model. We retrospectively evaluated 19 patients in PVS, categorizing them into two groups: those with improved consciousness ( = 7) and those without improvement ( = 12). Spectral and complexity analyses were performed on patients' EEG data to obtain spectral power and multiscale entropy (MSE) values. These metrics served as features in developing an EEG-based prediction model for consciousness improvement. Spectral power and MSE values were used as features in six machine learning models-support vector machine (SVM), Classification and Regression Tree, chi-squared automatic interaction detector, neural network, C5.0, and logistic regression-to perform classification via data mining methods. The dataset, containing data of 19 cases, was divided into training and test sets at a 50% ratio. The SVM model using MSE features yielded the best classification results, with prediction accuracies of 95.18% (training set) and 92.93% (test set). The logistic regression model achieved 93.25% and 84.51% accuracy, respectively. In the test set, the MSE-based SVM model demonstrated a 27.67% improvement in classification accuracy compared with models using spectral analysis features, indicating that MSE achieves better classification performance. This study demonstrates that MSE is a promising predictor of prognosis in patients in EEG-confirmed vegetative states.
准确区分持续性植物状态(PVS)和最低意识状态,并评估PVS患者的恢复可能性至关重要。本研究分析了脑电图(EEG)指标,以探讨它们与PVS患者意识改善之间的关系,并开发了一种机器学习预测模型。我们回顾性评估了19例PVS患者,将他们分为两组:意识改善组(n = 7)和未改善组(n = 12)。对患者的EEG数据进行频谱和复杂性分析,以获得频谱功率和多尺度熵(MSE)值。这些指标作为开发基于EEG的意识改善预测模型的特征。频谱功率和MSE值被用作六种机器学习模型(支持向量机(SVM)、分类与回归树、卡方自动交互检测器、神经网络、C5.0和逻辑回归)的特征,通过数据挖掘方法进行分类。包含19例数据的数据集以50%的比例分为训练集和测试集。使用MSE特征的SVM模型产生了最佳分类结果,训练集的预测准确率为95.18%,测试集的预测准确率为92.93%。逻辑回归模型的准确率分别为93.25%和84.51%。在测试集中,基于MSE的SVM模型与使用频谱分析特征的模型相比,分类准确率提高了27.67%,表明MSE具有更好的分类性能。本研究表明,MSE是脑电图确诊的植物状态患者预后的一个有前景的预测指标。