Burke Lucy C, Angus Colin, Brown Jamie, Kersbergen Inge
Sheffield Centre for Health and Related Research (SCHARR), University of Sheffield, Sheffield, UK.
Public Health and Epidemiology, University College London, London, UK.
BMJ Public Health. 2025 Sep 8;3(2):e002828. doi: 10.1136/bmjph-2025-002828. eCollection 2025.
The UK has promoted increased availability of alcohol-free and low-alcohol drinks (no/lo, ≤1.2% alcohol by volume) as a public health strategy. To be effective, no/lo beverages must replace, and not supplement, standard alcoholic drinks. Emerging evidence suggests that the reasons people drink alcohol may be an important determinant of the potential public health impact of these drinks. This study aimed to determine whether alcohol drinking motives were associated with no/lo consumption after accounting for sociodemographic characteristics and alcohol consumption.
A cross-sectional sample of adults residing in Great Britain (aged 16-93) who had drunk alcohol in the past year were recruited via the Alcohol Toolkit Study (N=2555; 49.0% female). The dependent variable was frequency of no/lo consumption (less than vs at least monthly). Five questions captured respondents' alcohol drinking motives (enhancement, social, conformity, coping-anxiety, and coping-depression), derived from the Drinking Motives Questionnaire-Revised. Sociodemographic characteristics, including age, gender, social grade, education, Index of Multiple Deprivation (a UK-wide measure of relative deprivation for small geographic areas), and hazardous alcohol use (Alcohol Use Disorder Identification Test), were also assessed. Descriptive analysis presents the proportion of respondents drinking no/lo at least monthly among low endorsement (ie, drinking for a motive less than half the time) versus high endorsement (ie, drinking for a motive at least half the time) of each drinking motive. Quasibinomial regression modelling explored relationships between alcohol drinking motives and no/lo consumption, accounting for sociodemographic characteristics and hazardous drinking.
Drinking alcohol to conform was associated with an increased likelihood of at least monthly no/lo consumption after accounting for sociodemographic characteristics and hazardous drinking (OR 1.10, 95% CI 1.00 to 1.21, p=0.041).
No/lo drinks may facilitate reduced alcohol consumption by offering an alternative for individuals wishing to participate in alcogenic environments. However, those who drink alcohol to conform are not typically higher-risk drinkers, which may limit the public health benefit of no/lo drinks. Further research is needed to explicitly explore substitution effects.
英国已将增加无酒精和低酒精饮料(无酒精/低酒精,酒精体积分数≤1.2%)的供应作为一项公共卫生策略。为了有效,无酒精/低酒精饮料必须替代而非补充标准酒精饮料。新出现的证据表明,人们饮酒的原因可能是这些饮料对公众健康潜在影响的一个重要决定因素。本研究旨在确定在考虑社会人口学特征和酒精消费情况后,饮酒动机是否与无酒精/低酒精饮料的消费有关。
通过酒精工具包研究招募了居住在英国(年龄在16 - 93岁之间)且在过去一年中饮酒的成年人横断面样本(N = 2555;49.0%为女性)。因变量是无酒精/低酒精饮料的消费频率(少于每月一次与至少每月一次)。五个问题捕捉了受访者的饮酒动机(增强、社交、从众、应对焦虑和应对抑郁),这些问题源自修订后的饮酒动机问卷。还评估了社会人口学特征,包括年龄、性别、社会阶层、教育程度、多重剥夺指数(英国范围内对小地理区域相对剥夺的一种衡量指标)以及有害酒精使用情况(酒精使用障碍识别测试)。描述性分析呈现了在每种饮酒动机的低认可度(即出于某种动机饮酒的时间少于一半)与高认可度(即出于某种动机饮酒的时间至少为一半)人群中,至少每月饮用一次无酒精/低酒精饮料的受访者比例。准二项式回归模型探讨了饮酒动机与无酒精/低酒精饮料消费之间的关系,同时考虑了社会人口学特征和有害饮酒情况。
在考虑社会人口学特征和有害饮酒情况后,因从众而饮酒与至少每月饮用一次无酒精/低酒精饮料的可能性增加相关(比值比1.10,95%置信区间1.00至1.21,p = 0.041)。
无酒精/低酒精饮料可能通过为希望参与含酒精环境的个人提供替代选择来促进减少酒精消费。然而,因从众而饮酒的人通常不是高风险饮酒者,这可能会限制无酒精/低酒精饮料对公众健康的益处。需要进一步研究来明确探讨替代效应。