Oftring Zoe S, Deutsch Kim, Holtz Svea, Köhler Susanne M, Chabiera Peter Jan, Dauletbaev Nurlan, Niekrenz Lukas, Müller Beate Sigrid, Kuhn Sebastian
Institute for Digital Medicine, Philipp's University Marburg and University Clinic Giessen & Marburg, Baldingerstrasse 1, 35043, Marburg, Germany.
Department of Pediatrics, University Clinic Giessen & Marburg, Philipp's University Marburg, Marburg, Germany.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2025 Sep 18;25(1):1203. doi: 10.1186/s12913-025-13455-5.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, infected outpatients were at risk of declining at home without themselves and their general practitioner (GP) noticing, above all due to silent hypoxemia. To support patients in quarantine, telemonitoring solutions were developed for primary care in several countries. However, evidence on patient perceptions of COVID-19 telemonitoring in primary care settings remains limited. This prospective study evaluates COVID-19 outpatients' experiences with and perception of the usability, utility and acceptance of an app-based telemonitoring in Germany, identifying key conditions for its successful implementation.
To support home-isolated COVID-19 patients remotely, eight GP practices in Germany implemented a multimodal telemonitoring system. Telemonitoring consisted of an app with connected sensors to remotely measure vital signs and symptoms, with data transmitted to a GP telemedicine platform. Between January to December 2021, 34 COVID-19 outpatients participated in telemonitoring. Telemonitoring duration was 28 days for acute infection or up to 12 weeks for prolonged/post-acute symptoms. Afterwards, patients participated in a mixed-methods evaluation about their experiences consisting of semi-structured telephone interviews and an in-house questionnaire. Interviews were analyzed using qualitative content analysis, questionnaires were analyzed descriptively.
All patients (34/34) completed the study (female = 22/34, 65%; median=50.5 years; range=19-74, comorbidities present = 13/34). Patients generally viewed telemonitoring as feasible and beneficial, with high acceptance rates and a perception of the system as valuable and reassuring support during illness. Participants, even those with limited prior experience in recording health data, successfully managed the monitoring process. Key insights included patient expectations regarding GP data access, underscoring the importance of integrating patient perspectives into the design process of future telemonitoring solutions. Connectivity issues with sensors occasionally disrupted data collection. Generally, the results emphasize the importance of comprehensive onboarding and support structures to optimize telemonitoring effectiveness.
This study demonstrates that app-based telemonitoring in primary care is a feasible, well-accepted intervention for COVID-19 outpatients, with patients perceiving it as valuable, supportive and reassuring. Findings emphasize the critical role of patient-centered design and strong support structures for successful telemonitoring integration into primary care. Lastly, these findings underscore the value of telemonitoring in pandemic preparedness, ensuring timely detection of patient deterioration and strengthening primary care resilience.
The study was registered with the German Clinical Trials Register (DRKS00024604). The study was approved by the Ethics Committee of Goethe University Frankfurt (No. 20-1023, 18.01.2021), and written informed consent was obtained from all participants.
在新冠疫情期间,新冠门诊患者存在在家中病情恶化却未被自己及全科医生察觉的风险,尤其是由于存在隐匿性低氧血症。为了帮助处于隔离状态的患者,多个国家开发了用于初级医疗保健的远程监测解决方案。然而,关于患者对初级医疗保健环境中新冠远程监测的看法的证据仍然有限。这项前瞻性研究评估了德国新冠门诊患者对基于应用程序的远程监测的可用性、实用性和可接受性的体验与看法,确定其成功实施的关键条件。
为了远程支持居家隔离的新冠患者,德国的8家全科医疗诊所实施了一个多模式远程监测系统。远程监测由一个与传感器相连的应用程序组成,用于远程测量生命体征和症状,并将数据传输到全科医生远程医疗平台。在2021年1月至12月期间,34名新冠门诊患者参与了远程监测。急性感染的远程监测时长为28天,对于长期/急性后症状则长达12周。之后,患者参与了一项关于他们体验的混合方法评估,包括半结构化电话访谈和一份内部问卷。访谈采用定性内容分析法进行分析,问卷采用描述性分析法进行分析。
所有患者(34/34)完成了研究(女性=22/34,65%;中位数=50.5岁;范围=19 - 74岁,有合并症的患者=13/34)。患者普遍认为远程监测是可行且有益的,接受率很高,并且认为该系统在患病期间是有价值且令人安心的支持。参与者,即使是那些之前在记录健康数据方面经验有限的人,也成功地完成了监测过程。关键见解包括患者对全科医生获取数据的期望,强调了将患者观点纳入未来远程监测解决方案设计过程的重要性。传感器的连接问题偶尔会干扰数据收集。总体而言,结果强调了全面的入职培训和支持结构对于优化远程监测效果的重要性。
这项研究表明,初级医疗保健中基于应用程序的远程监测对于新冠门诊患者是一种可行且广受接受的干预措施,患者认为它有价值、有支持作用且令人安心。研究结果强调了以患者为中心的设计和强大的支持结构对于将远程监测成功整合到初级医疗保健中的关键作用。最后,这些发现强调了远程监测在大流行防范中的价值,确保及时发现患者病情恶化并增强初级医疗保健的恢复能力。
该研究已在德国临床试验注册中心(DRKS00024604)注册。该研究获得了法兰克福歌德大学伦理委员会的批准(编号:20 - 1023,2021年1月18日),并获得了所有参与者的书面知情同意。