Weight Charlene, Laritz Rachael, Collins Simonne E, Mooney Meagan, Vinette Billy, Castiglione Sonia A, Straiton Nicola, Chicoine Gabrielle, Liang Shuang, Konnyu Kristin, Gagnon Marie-Pierre, Semenic Sonia, Middleton Sandy, Taylor Natalie, Bitzas Vasiliki Bessy, Folch Nathalie, Vachon Brigitte, Rouleau Geneviève, Patey Andrea, McCleary Nicola, Porat-Dahlerbruch Joshua, Fontaine Guillaume
Ingram School of Nursing, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, McGill University, Montréal, QC, Canada.
Centre for Clinical Epidemiology, Lady Davis Institute for Medical Research, Sir Mortimer B. Davis Jewish General Hospital, CIUSSS West-Central Montreal, 3755 Chem. de la Côte-Sainte-Catherine, Montréal, QC, Canada.
Transl Behav Med. 2025 Jan 16;15(1). doi: 10.1093/tbm/ibaf046.
Implementation strategies are essential for translating evidence into routine clinical practice. Their effectiveness depends on specifying and deploying behavior change techniques (BCTs): observable, irreducible components that target determinants of clinician behavior. The Behavior Change Technique Ontology (BCTO) standardizes the identification and labeling of BCTs, yet it has been applied only sparingly in implementation research to date.
To characterize the nature and extent of BCTs explicitly reported or retrospectively identified in implementation trials that targeted evidence-based nursing practice.
In this secondary analysis of a prior systematic review, we coded BCTs across 151 implementation trials with a manual derived from the 281-item BCTO. One to two coders per study applied coding rules in NVivo; disagreements were resolved by consensus. Feasibility indicators included coder certainty ("Definitely" vs "Probably" present) and the need for extra coding rules.
Trials contained 907 BCT instances: 857 in intervention arms, 50 in controls. We identified 100 of the BCTO's 281 techniques (35.6%), spanning 17 of its 20 parent groups. Intervention arms featured a median of four BCT instances (IQR 3-7) and four unique BCTs (IQR 3-5). The five most common BCTs were Instruct how to perform behavior (n = 273), Arrange informational support (n = 127), Deliver informational support (n = 83), Demonstrate behavior (n = 62), and Practice behavior (n = 43). Only 37% of BCT instances were coded with high certainty, and 17 supplementary decision rules were required for consistent coding.
Implementation strategies targeting nursing practice rely on instructional and informational BCTs, with limited use of goal-directed, feedback-intensive or context-altering techniques that could enhance impact.
The Clinical Trials Registration PROSPERO CRD42019130446.
