Ye Zhuojun, Tang Youyang, Chen Hangqi, Yang Jiying, Zhang Haoyu, Zhu Ruize, Li Xueying, Yuan Huiyun, He Jiangjiang, Jing Limei
School of Public Health, Shanghai Jiao Tong University School of Medicine, 227 South Chongqing Rd, Huangpu District, Shanghai, 200025, People's Republic of China.
School of Public Health, Shanghai University of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Shanghai, People's Republic of China.
BMC Public Health. 2025 Sep 24;25(1):3097. doi: 10.1186/s12889-025-24310-x.
With rising demand for hospice and palliative care nursing (HPCN) in nursing homes (NHs) worldwide, understanding older residents' HPCN preferences has become increasingly crucial. Given the diversity of these preferences across cultural and institutional contexts, a context-specific understanding is essential to developing services truly meet individual needs. Existing research mainly focuses on specific end-of-life aspects and lacks integrative frameworks to explain how broader HPCN preferences are shaped. This study aims to explore how older residents form their HPCN preferences within the interplay of Chinese cultural values and institutional environments and develop a theoretical framework explicating this formation process.
Using a grounded theory approach with purposive and theoretical sampling, 20 participants were selected from 5 NHs across urban and suburban areas. Data collection involved in-depth, semi-structured face-to-face interviews conducted between October 2021 and January 2022, with concurrent analysis based on Corbin and Strauss's method.
The analysis identified two contextual conditions shaping residents' preferences for HPCN: cultural context and NH environment. These conditions created cognitive and emotional challenges, categorized into limited understanding of HPCN and psychosocial disconnection. Consequently, residents expressed four main preferences: physical and emotional comfort, supporting relationality, collaborative decision-making, and continuity of care. A bidirectional relationship emerged, wherein challenges influenced preferences, and meeting these preferences helped mitigate challenges. Ultimately, the core concept of "navigating preferences for a trouble-free transition" emerged, capturing the varied and evolving preferences of older residents seeking care that minimizes burdens on both themselves and their families.
This study developed a theory on how contextual conditions and residents' cognitive and emotional challenges shape HPCN preferences. It highlights the diversity, variability, and individuality of these preferences, underscoring the need to enhance cultural sensitivity and care environments in Chinese NHs and comparable settings.
随着全球养老院对临终关怀与姑息护理(HPCN)的需求不断增加,了解老年居民对HPCN的偏好变得愈发关键。鉴于这些偏好在不同文化和机构背景下的多样性,特定背景下的理解对于开发真正满足个体需求的服务至关重要。现有研究主要集中在特定的临终方面,缺乏综合框架来解释更广泛的HPCN偏好是如何形成的。本研究旨在探讨老年居民在中国文化价值观与机构环境的相互作用中如何形成他们对HPCN的偏好,并构建一个理论框架来阐释这一形成过程。
采用扎根理论方法,通过目的性抽样和理论抽样,从城市和郊区的5家养老院中选取了20名参与者。数据收集包括在2021年10月至2022年1月期间进行的深入、半结构化面对面访谈,并基于科尔宾和施特劳斯的方法进行同步分析。
分析确定了塑造居民对HPCN偏好的两个背景条件:文化背景和养老院环境。这些条件带来了认知和情感挑战,分为对HPCN的理解有限和心理社会脱节。因此,居民表达了四个主要偏好:身体和情感舒适、支持人际关系、共同决策以及护理连续性。出现了一种双向关系,即挑战影响偏好,而满足这些偏好有助于减轻挑战。最终,出现了“为顺利过渡而引导偏好”这一核心概念,体现了寻求护理的老年居民多样化且不断演变的偏好,这些偏好能使他们自身及其家庭的负担最小化。
本研究构建了一个关于背景条件以及居民认知和情感挑战如何塑造HPCN偏好的理论。它强调了这些偏好的多样性、变异性和个体性,突显了在中国养老院及类似环境中增强文化敏感性和改善护理环境的必要性。