Martinez-Mier E Angeles, Castiblanco-Rubio Gina A, Tamayo-Cabeza Guillermo, Aguiar Andrea, Bashash Morteza, Bastain Tracy, Brunst Kelly, Breton Carrie, Cantoral Alejandra, Figueroa Jose L, Goodman Carly, Hu Howard, Ibarluzea-Maurolagoitia Jesus, Lanphear Bruce, Malin Ashley, Martinez Mauro, Peterson Karen E, Roberts Elizabeth F S, Schantz Susan, Subiza-Perez Mikel, Tamayo-Ortiz Marcela, Tellez-Rojo Martha M, Till Christine, Watkins Deborah J, Lippert Frank
School of Dentistry, Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN, USA.
Department of Veterinary Biosciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, IL, USA.
BMC Proc. 2025 Sep 29;19(Suppl 26):28. doi: 10.1186/s12919-025-00345-1.
Fluoride prevents dental caries in a dose-response manner, leading some countries to adjust fluoride levels in water or table salt, as well as to promote the widespread use of topical fluoride. Recent studies have found associations between prenatal fluoride exposure levels of < 1.5 mg/L in water and urine and adverse neurodevelopmental outcomes. Although high fluoride levels have been recognized as neurotoxic in the past, a large body of contemporary evidence derived from retrospective analyses of birth cohort studies suggests fluoride may be neurotoxic to children at lower levels, highlighting the need for further, prospective research and multidisciplinary collaborations. The International Fluoride Symposium, held from April 29 to 30, 2024, brought together 20 researchers from the United States, Canada, Mexico, and Spain to discuss the impacts of fluoride on human health and its mechanisms of action. The primary goals of the symposium were to address challenges related to assessing fluoride exposure, share findings from cohort studies, develop a comprehensive research agenda, and foster international research partnerships. Key discussions included the dental caries preventive and toxic effects of fluoride, sources of fluoride exposure, biomarkers, dietary intake assessment methods, and analytical challenges. Presentation of results from cohort studies highlighted research on prenatal fluoride exposure and its association with neurodevelopmental outcomes and presented perspectives for future analyses. The symposium emphasized the need for customized dietary fluoride intake assessment tools, the development of high-throughput analytical methods for fluoride analysis, and research on the combined effects of fluoride with other chemical elements commonly found in the environment and the human diet. Additionally, there was a call for the harmonization of cohort data from diverse populations to address urgent questions about the impact of fluoride on human neurodevelopment and other health outcomes beyond oral health. It was agreed that prospective longitudinal cohort studies intentionally designed to assess fluoride exposure and neurodevelopment are essential, as none of the existing birth cohorts were designed to specifically study fluoride exposure (e.g., selection of biomarkers, collection intervals, diet exposure assessment). Furthermore, broader environmental health cohort studies that incorporate high-quality biomonitoring of waterborne neurotoxicants (such as fluoride, arsenic, lead, mercury), repeated measures of exposure, and inclusion of key covariates (e.g., socio-economic status, diet, iodine) are encouraged. Finally, developing effective communication strategies among scientists and the public was considered crucial for advancing fluoride research and mitigating potential health risks.
氟化物以剂量反应方式预防龋齿,这使得一些国家调整饮用水或食盐中的氟化物含量,并推广局部用氟化物的广泛使用。最近的研究发现,水中和尿液中产前氟化物暴露水平低于1.5毫克/升与不良神经发育结果之间存在关联。尽管过去人们已认识到高氟水平具有神经毒性,但大量来自出生队列研究回顾性分析的当代证据表明,较低水平的氟化物可能对儿童具有神经毒性,这凸显了进一步开展前瞻性研究和多学科合作的必要性。2024年4月29日至30日举行的国际氟化物研讨会汇聚了来自美国、加拿大、墨西哥和西班牙的20名研究人员,讨论氟化物对人类健康的影响及其作用机制。该研讨会的主要目标是应对与评估氟化物暴露相关的挑战、分享队列研究的结果、制定全面的研究议程以及促进国际研究伙伴关系。主要讨论内容包括氟化物的防龋和毒性作用、氟化物暴露源、生物标志物、膳食摄入量评估方法以及分析挑战。队列研究结果的展示突出了关于产前氟化物暴露及其与神经发育结果关联的研究,并为未来分析提供了视角。该研讨会强调需要定制化的膳食氟化物摄入量评估工具、开发用于氟化物分析的高通量分析方法,以及研究氟化物与环境和人类饮食中常见的其他化学元素的联合作用。此外,有人呼吁统一来自不同人群的队列数据,以解决有关氟化物对人类神经发育及口腔健康以外的其他健康结果影响的紧迫问题。与会者一致认为,特意设计用于评估氟化物暴露和神经发育的前瞻性纵向队列研究至关重要,因为现有的出生队列均未设计用于专门研究氟化物暴露(例如生物标志物的选择、采集间隔、饮食暴露评估)。此外,鼓励开展更广泛的环境卫生队列研究,纳入对水中神经毒物(如氟化物、砷、铅、汞)的高质量生物监测、重复的暴露测量以及纳入关键协变量(如社会经济地位、饮食、碘)。最后,在科学家和公众之间制定有效的沟通策略被认为对于推进氟化物研究和降低潜在健康风险至关重要。