Khalil A, Sathianathan S
Tubercle. 1978 Mar;59(1):1-12. doi: 10.1016/0041-3879(77)90021-6.
The effect of legislative actions taken in 1973 on the prevalence of primary and acquired drug resistance was studied from the records on the Regional Tuberculosis and Chest Diseases Centre in Benghazi during the period June 1971 to August 1976. There were available for analysis 771 culture-positive cases of newly diagnosed pulmonary tuberculosis in Libyan nationals, and 789 cases of both Libyan nationals and others with positive cultures during treatment. The legislative actions included screening of all foreign and local workers for tuberculosis before employment or in the course of employement for those already employed and strict control of the use of antituberculosis drugs, which were not made available to private practitioners, private pharmacies, general dispensaries and general hospitals. The proportion of newly diagnosed cases with resistance to one or more of the 3 drugs streptomycin, isoniazid, PAS (resistance to PAS was negligible, occurring in only 0.7% of the whole series) during the first 3 months of the survey was 16.6%. During the first 9 3-month periods there was a small decrease of 0.15% per quarter. However, after adoption of the antituberculosis measures in mid-1973 the rate of decline accelerated to 0.61% per quarter, a 4-fold increase over the earlier rates (P less than 0.001 for comparison of rates). If the rate of decline observed in the first 9 quarters had continued unchanged the expected proportion resistant at the end of the period would have been 13.5%, compared with the observed proportion of 8.6%. The proportion of patients under treatment from whom resistant cultures were isolated was 33.3% in the first quarter. It remained at about this level until the 14th quarter, approximately a year after the legislation came into force, when the proportion began to decline. By the end of the period it was only 14.7%.
从班加西地区结核病与胸部疾病中心1971年6月至1976年8月期间的记录,研究了1973年采取的立法行动对原发性和获得性耐药性流行情况的影响。可供分析的有771例新诊断为肺结核的利比亚国民培养阳性病例,以及789例治疗期间培养阳性的利比亚国民和其他人员的病例。立法行动包括在就业前或对已就业人员在就业期间对所有外国和当地工人进行结核病筛查,以及严格控制抗结核药物的使用,这些药物不对私人执业医生、私人药房、普通药房和综合医院提供。在调查的前3个月中,新诊断出对链霉素、异烟肼、对氨基水杨酸这3种药物中的一种或多种耐药的病例比例(对氨基水杨酸耐药可忽略不计,仅占整个系列的0.7%)为16.6%。在最初的9个3个月期间,每季度有0.15%的小幅下降。然而,1973年年中采取抗结核措施后,下降速度加快至每季度0.61%,比早期速度增加了4倍(比较速度时P<0.001)。如果在最初9个季度观察到的下降速度保持不变,该时期末预期的耐药比例将为13.5%,而观察到的比例为8.6%。治疗患者中分离出耐药培养物的比例在第一季度为33.3%。在第14个季度之前,即立法生效约一年后,该比例一直保持在这一水平左右,之后开始下降。到该时期末,仅为14.7%。