Holdstock G, Wiseman M, Loehry C A
Br Med J. 1979 Feb 17;1(6161):457-9. doi: 10.1136/bmj.1.6161.457.
An open-access general-practitioner referral service for endoscopy of the upper gastrointestinal tract was established in a district general hospital, and the impact of the service over three years was assessed. The reason for referral, duration of symptoms, and amount of disease detected were the same in patients referred by general practitioners and those attending from hospital outpatient departments. Despite a steady increase in the number of patients referred for endoscopy, the number of barium-meal examinations performed did not correspondingly decrease. The number of ulcers and cancers detected in each six-month period of the study did not increase, and the combined overall pick-up rate for these two conditions fell from 25% to 13%. All general practitioners in the area were sent questionnaires. Most thought that clinic referral had been reduced and patient management helped as a result of the introduction of the service. While the value of negative endoscopic findings cannot be assessed, there is little objective evidence of benefit. Hence the large increase in numbers of endoscopies performed as a result of the introduction of the service cannot be justified.
一家地区综合医院设立了一项上消化道内镜检查的开放获取全科医生转诊服务,并评估了该服务三年来的影响。全科医生转诊的患者与医院门诊就诊的患者在转诊原因、症状持续时间和检出疾病数量方面相同。尽管转诊接受内镜检查的患者数量稳步增加,但进行的钡餐检查数量并未相应减少。研究的每六个月期间检测到的溃疡和癌症数量没有增加,这两种疾病的综合总体检出率从25%降至13%。该地区所有全科医生都收到了问卷。大多数人认为由于该服务的引入,诊所转诊减少了,患者管理得到了帮助。虽然内镜检查阴性结果的价值无法评估,但几乎没有客观的获益证据。因此,由于引入该服务而导致的内镜检查数量大幅增加是不合理的。