Ferguson D
Br J Ind Med. 1972 Oct;29(4):420-31. doi: 10.1136/oem.29.4.420.
420-431. Several studies have shown that frequency of absence attributed to sickness is not distributed randomly but tends to follow the negative binomial distribution, and this has been taken to support the concept of `proneness' to such absence. Thus, the distribution of sickness absence resembles that of minor injury at work demonstrated over 50 years ago. Because the investigation of proneness to absence does not appear to have been reported by others in Australia, the opportunity was taken, during a wider study of health among telegraphists in a large communications undertaking, to analyse some characteristics of repeated sickness absence. The records of medically certified and uncertified sickness absence of all 769 telegraphists continuously employed in all State capitals over a two-and-a-half-year period were compared with those of 411 clerks and 415 mechanics and, in Sydney, 380 mail sorters and 80 of their supervisors. All telegraphists in Sydney, Melbourne, and Brisbane, and all mail sorters in Sydney, who were available and willing were later medically examined. From their absence pattern repeaters (employees who had had eight or more certified absences in two and a half years) were separated into three types based on a presumptive origin in chance, recurrent disease and symptomatic non-specific disorder. The observed distribution of individual frequency of certified absence over the full two-and-a-half-year period of study followed that expected from the univariate negative binomial, using maximum likelihood estimators, rather than the poisson distribution, in three of the four occupational groups in Sydney. Limited correlational and bivariate analysis supported the interpretation of proneness ascribed to the univariate fit. In the two groups studied, frequency of uncertified absence could not be fitted by the negative binomial, although the numbers of such absences in individuals in successive years were relatively highly correlated. All types of repeater were commoner in Sydney than in the other capital city offices, which differed little from each other. Repeaters were more common among those whose absence was attributed to neurosis, alimentary and upper respiratory tract disorder, and injury. Out of more than 90 health, personal, social, and industrial attributes determined at examination, only two (ethanol habit and adverse attitude to pay) showed any statistically significant association when telegraphist repeaters in Sydney were compared with employees who were rarely absent. Though repeating tended to be associated with chronic or recurrent ill health revealed at examination, one quarter of repeaters had little such ill health and one quarter of rarely absent employees had much. It was concluded that, in the population studied, the fitting of the negative binomial to frequency of certified sickness absence could, in the circumstances of the study, reasonably be given an interpretation of proneness. In that population also repeating varies geographically and occupationally, and is poorly associated with disease and other attributes uncovered at examination, with the exception of the ethanol habit. Repeaters are more often neurotic than employees who are rarely absent but also are more often stable double jobbers. The repeater should be identified for what help may be given him, if needed, otherwise it would seem more profitable to attack those features in work design and organization which influence motivation to come to work. Social factors which predispose to repeated absence are less amenable to modification.
420 - 431。多项研究表明,因疾病导致的缺勤频率并非随机分布,而是倾向于遵循负二项分布,这一点被用来支持“易患性”这一概念。因此,病假缺勤的分布类似于50多年前所证明的工作中轻伤的分布情况。由于在澳大利亚似乎没有其他人报道过对缺勤易患性的调查,所以在对一家大型通信企业的报务员进行更广泛的健康研究期间,趁机分析了反复病假缺勤的一些特征。将在两年半时间里一直在所有州首府连续受雇的769名报务员经医学证明和未经医学证明的病假缺勤记录,与411名职员、415名机械师以及悉尼的380名邮件分拣员及其80名主管的记录进行了比较。悉尼、墨尔本和布里斯班的所有报务员以及悉尼所有愿意且有空的邮件分拣员随后都接受了医学检查。根据在两年半时间里有八次或更多经证明缺勤的重复缺勤者(员工)的缺勤模式,基于偶然、复发性疾病和症状性非特异性疾病的推测性起因,将他们分为三种类型。在悉尼的四个职业群体中的三个群体中,在整个两年半的研究期间观察到的经证明缺勤的个体频率分布遵循使用最大似然估计量的单变量负二项分布所预期的情况,而不是泊松分布。有限的相关性和双变量分析支持了将易患性归因于单变量拟合的解释。在所研究的两个群体中,未经证明的缺勤频率无法用负二项分布拟合,尽管连续几年中个体的此类缺勤次数具有相对较高的相关性。所有类型的重复缺勤者在悉尼都比在其他首府城市办公室更为常见,而其他首府城市办公室之间差异不大。重复缺勤者在那些缺勤归因于神经症、消化道和上呼吸道疾病以及损伤的人群中更为常见。在检查时确定的90多种健康、个人、社会和职业属性中,当将悉尼的报务员重复缺勤者与很少缺勤的员工进行比较时,只有两项(饮酒习惯和对薪酬的负面态度)显示出任何统计学上的显著关联。尽管重复缺勤往往与检查时发现的慢性或复发性健康问题相关,但四分之一的重复缺勤者几乎没有此类健康问题,而四分之一很少缺勤的员工却有很多。得出的结论是,在所研究的人群中,在研究的情况下,将负二项分布应用于经证明的病假缺勤频率可以合理地解释为易患性。在该人群中,重复缺勤在地理和职业上也存在差异,并且与检查时发现的疾病和其他属性关联不大,饮酒习惯除外。重复缺勤者比很少缺勤的员工更常患神经症,但他们也更常是稳定的兼职者。应识别出重复缺勤者,以便在需要时给予帮助,否则,似乎更有利可图的做法是解决工作设计和组织中影响上班动机的那些因素。导致反复缺勤的社会因素较难改变。