Oosterhuis H, Bethlem J
J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry. 1973 Apr;36(2):244-54. doi: 10.1136/jnnp.36.2.244.
An investigation was made into the occurrence of muscular atrophy and muscular pathology in a series of 170 patients with myasthenia gravis. The results can be summarized as follows: (1) Of the 148 patients with generalized myasthenia gravis, 14 showed local muscular atrophies. Of 10 biopsies from atrophic muscles, eight showed neurogenic changes, with or without lymphocytic infiltrations. One biopsy showed lymphocytic infiltrations only, and one showed type II-fibre atrophy (Table 1). No relationship was demonstrable between the presence of clilnical muscular atrophy and age, sex, duration of the disease, severity of the disease, presence of a thymoma, or drug resistant ophthalmoplegia. (2) In this group of patients 61 biopsies were examined from 46 individuals; 40 of these biopsies were taken from the quadriceps muscle. A thymoma was present in 17 patients. Examination disclosed neurogenic changes in 17 biopsies, lymphocytic infiltrates in 21, and myositis in one biopsy (Table 2). A distinct correlation was established between the presence of a thymoma and lymphocytic infiltrates, but none was demonstrable between thymoma and neurogenic changes (Table 3). (3) An enzyme-histochemical study was carried out in 35 cases, including 12 with neurogenic changes. A normal differentiation of type I- and type II-fibres was observed in eight instances, type grouping of type II-fibres in three, and type II-fibre atrophy in two cases. (4) In 21 patients and 19 controls, the smallest mean diameter was determined in the quadriceps muscle. Both type I- and type II-fibres proved to have a smaller mean diameter in the female patients than in the controls. In the male patients this could not be proven. (5) Of the eight patients who had died without disorders of ventilation, 90 muscle specimens were examined postmortem. Four of these patients had a thymoma. Lymphocytic infiltrations, found in 32 biopsy specimens, were mostly observed in the presence of a thymoma. Neurogenic changes were apparently unrelated to the presence of a thymoma (Tables 5 and 6). The post mortem examination included the spinal cord in five, and peripheral nerves in three cases. No abnormalities were found. (6) The muscular atrophy found in patients with myasthenia is not a myopathy but an affection of the lower motor neurone. Neurogenic changes were regularly found in the muscles of patients with myasthenia, even without muscular atrophy. The finding of these changes is no reason to reject the diagnosis. It is postulated that denervation occurs at the neuromuscular junction as a result of permanent absence of acetylcholine.
对170例重症肌无力患者的肌肉萎缩和肌肉病理情况进行了调查。结果总结如下:(1) 在148例全身型重症肌无力患者中,14例出现局部肌肉萎缩。在取自萎缩肌肉的10份活检标本中,8份显示神经源性改变,伴有或不伴有淋巴细胞浸润。1份活检标本仅显示淋巴细胞浸润,1份显示Ⅱ型纤维萎缩(表1)。临床肌肉萎缩的存在与年龄、性别、病程、病情严重程度、胸腺瘤的存在或药物抵抗性眼肌麻痹之间未显示出相关性。(2) 在这组患者中,对46例个体的61份活检标本进行了检查;其中40份活检标本取自股四头肌。17例患者存在胸腺瘤。检查发现17份活检标本有神经源性改变,21份有淋巴细胞浸润,1份活检标本有肌炎(表2)。胸腺瘤的存在与淋巴细胞浸润之间建立了明显的相关性,但胸腺瘤与神经源性改变之间未显示出相关性(表3)。(3) 对35例患者进行了酶组织化学研究,其中12例有神经源性改变。8例观察到Ⅰ型和Ⅱ型纤维正常分化,3例观察到Ⅱ型纤维群组化,2例观察到Ⅱ型纤维萎缩。(4) 在21例患者和19例对照中,测定了股四头肌的最小平均直径。女性患者的Ⅰ型和Ⅱ型纤维平均直径均小于对照组。男性患者未证实有此情况。(5) 在8例无通气障碍死亡的患者中,对90份肌肉标本进行了尸检。其中4例患者有胸腺瘤。在32份活检标本中发现淋巴细胞浸润,大多在有胸腺瘤的情况下观察到。神经源性改变显然与胸腺瘤的存在无关(表5和表6)。尸检包括5例的脊髓和3例的周围神经。未发现异常。(6) 重症肌无力患者中发现的肌肉萎缩不是肌病,而是下运动神经元的病变。重症肌无力患者的肌肉中经常发现神经源性改变,即使没有肌肉萎缩。这些改变的发现不是拒绝诊断的理由。据推测,由于乙酰胆碱长期缺乏,神经肌肉接头处发生去神经支配。