Starfield B, Steinwachs D, Morris I, Bause G, Siebert S, Westin C
Am J Public Health. 1979 Oct;69(10):1021-5. doi: 10.2105/ajph.69.10.1021.
In this study in an urban practice, the presence of a neutral observer at follow-up visits enhanced the extent to which practitioners recognized problems which patients had in a previous visit. This improvement was limited to those problems which initially had been mentioned by patients as requiring follow-up. Follow-up of problems initially mentioned by practitioners as needing follow-up was not improved by the observer unless the problem was also mentioned by the patient. Investigators whose information about practitioner-patient interaction depends upon the presence of an observer should be aware of this and possibly other effects. Although routine involvement of a neutral observer in patient-practitioner interactions is probably undesirable, selected deployment of observers or similar alternatives may be useful in situations where practitioner-patient communication is inadequate.
在这项针对城市医疗实践的研究中,随访时安排一名中立观察者可提高医生识别患者在前次就诊时所存在问题的程度。这种改善仅限于那些患者最初提及需要随访的问题。除非患者也提到了问题,否则观察者并不会改善医生最初提及需要随访问题的随访情况。那些依赖观察者在场来获取医患互动信息的研究者应该意识到这一点以及可能存在的其他影响。虽然让中立观察者常规参与医患互动可能并不可取,但在医患沟通不足的情况下,有选择地安排观察者或类似替代方式可能会有所帮助。