Elston H R, Baudo J A, Stanek J P, Schaab M
Appl Microbiol. 1971 Sep;22(3):408-14. doi: 10.1128/am.22.3.408-414.1971.
A multi-biochemical test system consisting of nine tests, entitled Enterotube, was evaluated in parallel with conventional tests to determine its value in the identification of enteric and certain other gram-negative bacilli. The 242 bacterial strains studied were from a variety of pathological specimens and from our culture collection. When the results with individual tests represented in both test systems were compared, no discrepancies were noted in the indole test, and one discrepancy was recorded for dextrose. In 7 of 242 hydrogen sulfide tests, 3 of 242 phenylalanine tests, 22 of 242 urease tests, 15 of 242 dulcitol tests, 12 of 242 lactose tests, 27 of 217 lysine decarboxylase tests, and 5 of 242 citrate tests, the Enterotube results were contrary to those obtained with conventional methods. The lysine decarboxylase test in the Enterotube posed a problem of interpretation and readability and is not an acceptable alternative to the conventional methods. Fifteen of the strains studied were incorrectly identified by the Enterotube system and four could not be differentiated from other closely related strains. Salmonella could be identified as to group, whereas Shigella strains were frequently misidentified as Escherichia. The Enterotube method is simple and convenient, and all media are inoculated at once from a single colony.
一种包含九项检测的多生化检测系统,名为肠道菌鉴定管(Enterotube),与传统检测方法并行评估,以确定其在鉴定肠道菌及某些其他革兰氏阴性杆菌方面的价值。所研究的242株细菌菌株来自各种病理标本以及我们的菌种保藏库。当比较两个检测系统中各项检测的结果时,吲哚检测未发现差异,葡萄糖检测记录到一处差异。在242次硫化氢检测中有7次、242次苯丙氨酸检测中有3次、242次尿素酶检测中有22次、242次卫矛醇检测中有15次、242次乳糖检测中有12次、217次赖氨酸脱羧酶检测中有27次以及242次柠檬酸盐检测中有5次,肠道菌鉴定管的结果与传统方法所得结果相反。肠道菌鉴定管中的赖氨酸脱羧酶检测存在解释和读数问题,并非传统方法的可接受替代方法。所研究的菌株中有15株被肠道菌鉴定管系统错误鉴定,4株无法与其他密切相关菌株区分开来。沙门氏菌可按菌群鉴定,而志贺氏菌菌株常被误鉴定为大肠杆菌。肠道菌鉴定管方法简单方便,所有培养基都从单个菌落一次性接种。