Holburn A M, Frame M, Hughes-Jones N C, Mollison P L
Immunology. 1971 May;20(5):681-91.
Twelve previously uninjected D-negative subjects were given 1 ml of D-positive cells together with 30–90 μg IgM anti-D intravenously; about 50 per cent of the cells were cleared within 48 hours, and the remainder were cleared far more slowly; at 6 months two of the subjects had formed anti-D. All subjects were then given a second injection of D-positive red cells but without passive antibody; two subjects without demonstrable anti-D at the time of this injection showed accelerated clearance within the first week and developed anti-D within 6 weeks. The proportion of subjects forming anti-D (four out of twelve) was not significantly different from that found in a previous series injected with red cells alone and it was concluded that these doses of IgM anti-D had failed to suppress immunization. It has previously been proposed that the proper criterion for judging augmentation of immune responses in D-negative subjects is not the proportion of subjects becoming immunized but rather the characteristics of the response in subjects capable of responding. In the present series no definite evidence was obtained that antibody formation was brisker or greater in those subjects who received passive IgM antibody together with their first injection of D-positive red cells.
12名之前未注射过的D阴性受试者静脉注射了1毫升D阳性细胞以及30 - 90微克IgM抗D;约50%的细胞在48小时内被清除,其余细胞清除得要慢得多;6个月时,有两名受试者产生了抗D。然后所有受试者再次注射D阳性红细胞,但未注射被动抗体;在此次注射时没有可检测到的抗D的两名受试者在第一周内显示出清除加速,并在6周内产生了抗D。产生抗D的受试者比例(12名中有4名)与之前仅注射红细胞的系列研究中发现的比例没有显著差异,得出的结论是这些剂量的IgM抗D未能抑制免疫。此前有人提出,判断D阴性受试者免疫反应增强的合适标准不是免疫的受试者比例,而是有反应能力的受试者的反应特征。在本系列研究中,没有获得明确证据表明,在首次注射D阳性红细胞时同时接受被动IgM抗体的受试者中,抗体形成更迅速或更多。