Harrow M, Silverstein M L
Schizophr Bull. 1977;3(4):608-16. doi: 10.1093/schbul/3.4.608.
Sixty schizophrenic and 34 nonschizophrenic patients were assessed 3 years after discharge on 17 types of psychotic symptoms. Schizophrenics were significantly higher than nonschizophrenic patients on the overall index of psychotic features (p less than .01) and on the index of delusions (p less than .01). Using a weighted estimate, 38.5 percent of the nonparanoid schiziphrenics showed clear evidence of psychotic features, and another 20.5 percent showed some evidence of psychotic features which were weak or sporadic or which the patients seemed able to bring into perspective. Schizophrenic subdiagnosis did not predict later psychotic sysmptoms, although there was a trend for more psychotic features in paranoid and in chronic schizophrenics. The belief that psychotic symptoms in schiziphrenia are not just temporary states was supported. However, conceptions about psychotic symptoms persisting in all schizophrenics were not affirmed.
60名精神分裂症患者和34名非精神分裂症患者在出院3年后接受了17种精神症状的评估。精神分裂症患者在精神症状总体指标(p<0.01)和妄想指标(p<0.01)上显著高于非精神分裂症患者。采用加权估计,38.5%的非偏执型精神分裂症患者有明显的精神症状证据,另外20.5%有一些精神症状证据,这些症状较弱或偶发,或者患者似乎能够正确看待。精神分裂症的亚型诊断并不能预测后期的精神症状,尽管偏执型和慢性精神分裂症患者有更多精神症状的趋势。精神分裂症中的精神症状不只是暂时状态这一观点得到了支持。然而,关于所有精神分裂症患者精神症状持续存在的观念并未得到证实。