Doherty M, Watt I, Dieppe P
Lancet. 1983 Jul 2;2(8340):8-11. doi: 10.1016/s0140-6736(83)90003-x.
The hands and knees of 150 patients who had undergone unilateral meniscectomy 19 or more (mean 24 . 7) years before were examined for evidence of osteoarthritis (OA). 65 had X-ray changes in the hands consistent with primary generalised OA. These patients showed more frequent and more severe knee OA, judged clinically and radiologically, in both unoperated and operated knees, than did the 85 patients without hand OA. The increased frequency in operated knees was independent of sex and age variables between the groups and remained significant after exclusion of patients with OA on the unoperated side. This study demonstrated that predisposition to "primary" OA influences the development and severity of "secondary" OA. It invalidates clear distinction between these subsets and emphasises the multifactorial nature of the disease.
对150例患者进行了检查,这些患者在19年或更久之前(平均24.7年)接受了单侧半月板切除术,以寻找骨关节炎(OA)的证据。65例患者手部X线改变符合原发性全身性骨关节炎。与85例无手部OA的患者相比,这些患者在未手术侧和手术侧膝关节的OA,经临床和放射学判断,均更为常见且更为严重。手术侧膝关节OA发生率的增加与两组间的性别和年龄变量无关,在排除未手术侧有OA的患者后仍具有显著性。本研究表明,“原发性”OA的易感性会影响“继发性”OA的发生和严重程度。这使得这些亚组之间无法进行明确区分,并强调了该疾病的多因素性质。