Gory C, Tannières-Ruffié M L, Vourc'h G
Ann Fr Anesth Reanim. 1983;2(1):32-4. doi: 10.1016/S0750-7658(83)80047-1.
52 patients selected at random were assigned to four groups according to the surgery and muscle relaxant used: vecuronium (group A) and suxamethonium (group B) in ENT, vecuronium (group C) and suxamethonium (group D) for laser surgery. The first dose of vecuronium was 0.05 mg X kg-1, followed by repeat doses of 0.0125 mg X kg-1; suxamethonium was first given in a dose of 1 mg X kg-1, this being followed by a drip of 3 mg X kg-1. The anaesthetic protocol was the same for all groups. The results showed a shorter onset of action with suxamethonium (group A: 210 +/- 30 s, group B: 75 +/- 15 s, group C: 200 +/- 50 s, group D: 80 +/- 20 s) and a similar duration of action for the initial doses of the two drugs (group A: 9 +/- 3 min, group B: 6 +/- 3 min, group C: 11 +/- 4 min, group D: 7 +/- 2 min). Continuing the muscle relaxation proved easier with the suxamethonium; signs of decurarization occurred rather unexpectedly with vecuronium. No adverse effect was seen with vecuronium, whilst the diastolic blood pressure rose 20% during the first 25 min following the administration of suxamethonium. It can be concluded that, in the absence of monitoring of the curarization, the repeated administration of vecuronium with a first dose of 0.05 mg X kg-1 brought few advantages compared with the continuous infusion of suxamethonium.
随机选取52例患者,根据所采用的手术方式和肌肉松弛剂分为四组:耳鼻喉手术中使用维库溴铵(A组)和琥珀胆碱(B组),激光手术中使用维库溴铵(C组)和琥珀胆碱(D组)。维库溴铵首剂为0.05mg/kg,随后重复剂量为0.0125mg/kg;琥珀胆碱首剂为1mg/kg,随后以3mg/kg持续静脉滴注。所有组的麻醉方案相同。结果显示,琥珀胆碱起效时间更短(A组:210±30秒,B组:75±15秒,C组:200±50秒,D组:80±20秒),两种药物初始剂量的作用持续时间相似(A组:9±3分钟,B组:6±3分钟,C组:11±4分钟,D组:7±2分钟)。持续使用琥珀胆碱维持肌肉松弛更容易;使用维库溴铵时,恢复自主呼吸的征象出现得相当意外。维库溴铵未观察到不良反应,而使用琥珀胆碱后,在前25分钟内舒张压升高了20%。可以得出结论,在未监测肌松的情况下,首剂0.05mg/kg的维库溴铵重复给药与持续输注琥珀胆碱相比,优势不大。