Wallace R L, VanDorsten J P, Eglinton G S, Meuller E, McCart D, Schifrin B S
J Reprod Med. 1984 Oct;29(10):745-8.
We considered 113 consecutive patients for attempted external cephalic version with tocolysis (ECV-T) after 37 weeks' gestation. We randomized the first patients to the control group (no ECV-T attempted, 23 patients) or the study group (ECV-T attempted, 25 patients). Nine patients were excluded, and ECV-T was then considered for 88 patients, with a success rate of 77% for the 104 total attempts. Six patients were lost to follow-up. In the successful ECV-T group, 71 of 75 patients (95%) presented the vertex in labor, while 4 patients (5%) reverted to breech. Uterine exploration at delivery revealed uterine anomalies in three of the patients who reverted. The cesarean rate was 25% in the successful-ECV-T group and 87% in the failed-ECV-T group. In the initial group, four patients (18%) spontaneously converted to cephalic presentations after 37 weeks. None of the failed-ECV-T patients spontaneously converted to cephalic presentations. The cesarean rate for the control and failed-ECV-T patients presenting the breech intrapartum was 88%. Complications included transient fetal bradycardia in 37 patients (36%), evidence of fetomaternal bleeding (positive Kleihauer-Betke test) in 2 patients (2%) and one fetal demise three weeks following successful ECV-T and diagnosed at the onset of labor. We lowered the cesarean section rate for breech presentation in labor with the selective application of ECV-T late in gestation. We consider this technique to be a powerful addition to our armamentarium for managing the term breech presentation.
我们纳入了113例妊娠37周后尝试行外倒转术联合宫缩抑制剂(ECV-T)的连续病例。我们将首批患者随机分为对照组(未尝试ECV-T,23例患者)或研究组(尝试ECV-T,25例患者)。9例患者被排除,之后对88例患者考虑行ECV-T,104次总尝试的成功率为77%。6例患者失访。在成功进行ECV-T的组中,75例患者中有71例(95%)在分娩时为头先露,而4例患者(5%)转为臀先露。分娩时的子宫探查发现3例转为臀先露的患者存在子宫异常。成功进行ECV-T的组剖宫产率为25%,失败进行ECV-T的组为87%。在最初的组中,4例患者(18%)在37周后自然转为头先露。失败进行ECV-T的患者中无1例自然转为头先露。对照组和分娩时为臀先露的失败进行ECV-T的患者剖宫产率为88%。并发症包括37例患者(36%)出现短暂性胎儿心动过缓,2例患者(2%)有母胎出血证据(Kleihauer-Betke试验阳性),1例在成功进行ECV-T后3周出现胎儿死亡,且在临产时确诊。通过在妊娠晚期选择性应用ECV-T,我们降低了分娩时臀先露的剖宫产率。我们认为该技术是我们处理足月臀先露的有力补充手段。