A search for protein cores in chromosomes: is the scaffold an artifact?

A protein chromosome scaffold structure has been proposed that acts as a structural framework for attachment of chromosomal DNA. There are several troubling aspects of this concept: (1) such structures have not been seen in many previous thin-section and whole-mount electron microscopy studies of metaphase chromosomes, while they are readily seen in leptotene and zygotene chromosomes; (2) such a structure poses problems for sister chromatid exchanges; and (3) the published photographs show a marked variation in the amount of scaffold in different whole-mount preparations. An alternative explanation is that the scaffold in whole-mount preparations represents incomplete dispersion of the high concentration of chromatin in the center of chromosomes, and when the histones are removed and the DNA dispersed, the remaining nonhistone proteins (NHPs) aggregate to form a chromosome-shaped structure. Two studies were done to determine if the scaffold is real or an artifact: (1) Chinese hamster mitotic cells and isolated chromosomes were examined using two protein stains -EDTA-regressive staining and phosphotungstic acid (PTA) stain. The EDTA-regressive stain showed ribonucleoprotein particles at the periphery of the chromosomes but nothing at the center of the chromosomes. The PTA stain showed the kinetochore plates but no central structures; and (2) isolated chromosomes were partially dispersed to decrease the high concentration of chromatin in the center of the chromosome, then treated with 4 M ammonium acetate or 2 M NaCl to dehistonize them and disperse the DNA. Under these circumstances, no chromosome scaffold was seen. We conclude that the scaffold structure is an artifact resulting from incomplete dispersion of central chromatin and aggregation of NHPs in dehistonized chromosomes.