Burgess D B, Asher K N, Doucet H J, Reardon K, Daste M L
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 1984 Aug;5(4):195-200.
The increasing emphasis on screening the pediatric population for developmental delays requires that rapid and efficient screening tests be developed and evaluated. This study assessed the ability of three rapid screening procedures to predict full Denver Developmental Screening Test (DDST) results. Ninety children were randomly assigned to one of three prescreening groups. The first group was prescreened with the Prescreening Developmental Questionnaire (PDQ), administered in the "standard" fashion, i.e., mother reads and answers 10 questions about her child's development. The second group was prescreened using a modified means of administering the PDQ (PDQ-M); a health care professional read each PDQ question to the mother. The third group was prescreened with the Alpern-Boll Developmental Profile II, a relatively lengthy procedure utilizing parent report information. All of the children were then tested with the DDST. Each of the prescreening procedures was highly predictive of performance on the DDST. The Alpern-Boll profile, as anticipated, demonstrated greater validity than the PDQ and PDQ-M on six of seven indices of prescreening test validity, generated from a four-group referral matrix. The PDQ-M was more similar to the Alpern-Boll on four indices, while the PDQ was more similar on three. It was judged that the two PDQ procedures were equivalent in their validity characteristics. The PDQ-M appears to be an acceptable means of rapidly screening preschool children for developmental delays.
对儿科人群发育迟缓进行筛查的重视程度日益增加,这就要求开发并评估快速有效的筛查测试。本研究评估了三种快速筛查程序预测完整丹佛发育筛查测试(DDST)结果的能力。90名儿童被随机分配到三个预筛查组中的一组。第一组使用预筛查发育问卷(PDQ)进行预筛查,采用“标准”方式,即母亲阅读并回答10个关于其孩子发育情况的问题。第二组使用一种修改后的PDQ施测方式(PDQ-M)进行预筛查;由一名医疗保健专业人员向母亲朗读每个PDQ问题。第三组使用阿尔珀恩 - 博尔发育量表II进行预筛查,这是一个相对冗长的程序,利用家长报告信息。然后所有儿童都接受了DDST测试。每种预筛查程序对DDST表现都具有高度预测性。正如预期的那样,从四组转诊矩阵得出的预筛查测试有效性的七个指标中,阿尔珀恩 - 博尔量表在六个指标上比PDQ和PDQ-M表现出更高的效度。在四个指标上,PDQ-M与阿尔珀恩 - 博尔量表更为相似,而在三个指标上,PDQ与阿尔珀恩 - 博尔量表更为相似。判断这两种PDQ程序在效度特征上是等效的。PDQ-M似乎是一种可接受的快速筛查学龄前儿童发育迟缓的方法。