Bernstein J
Am J Med. 1983 Oct 31;75(4B):70-4. doi: 10.1016/0002-9343(83)90331-5.
Fenbufen (Cinopal) has been evaluated extensively in 155 clinical trials, including 102 in rheumatoid arthritis and 53 in osteoarthritis. Forty-nine of these trials involving 12 protocols have been identified as pivotal. All 12 protocols (six rheumatoid arthritis and six osteoarthritis) were double-blind and controlled, with the duration of treatment ranging from four weeks to one year, and included sufficient patient populations to detect important differences in efficacy between fenbufen and the reference agents. Evaluation of the efficacy results was based on the standard parameters commonly measured for rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis. The primary evaluation point was the end of four weeks of therapy. Results of the 49 studies employing the 12 pivotal protocols, demonstrated that fenbufen, given in divided daily doses of 600 to 1,000 mg, provided significant anti-inflammatory effects. These effects were superior to placebo and comparable to those attained with full therapeutic doses of aspirin, indomethacin, phenylbutazone, and ozyphenbutazone. Long-term trials provided important information as to the relative effectiveness and tolerance of fenbufen in the management of patients with rheumatoid arthritis and osteoarthritis. The proportion of fenbufen-treated patients able to continue long-term therapy was substantially greater than the proportion of aspirin-, indomethacin-, or placebo-treated patients. Results from these trials indicate that fenbufen provides a more favorable ratio of benefit to risk than either aspirin or indomethacin.
联苯乙酸(西诺帕)已在155项临床试验中得到广泛评估,其中包括102项类风湿性关节炎试验和53项骨关节炎试验。这些试验中有49项涉及12个方案,已被确定为关键试验。所有12个方案(6个类风湿性关节炎方案和6个骨关节炎方案)均为双盲对照试验,治疗持续时间从4周到1年不等,且纳入了足够数量的患者群体,以检测联苯乙酸与参比药物在疗效上的重要差异。疗效结果的评估基于类风湿性关节炎和骨关节炎常用的标准参数。主要评估点为治疗4周结束时。采用这12个关键方案的49项研究结果表明,联苯乙酸每日分剂量600至1000毫克给药,具有显著的抗炎作用。这些作用优于安慰剂,且与全治疗剂量的阿司匹林、吲哚美辛、保泰松和羟保泰松相当。长期试验提供了关于联苯乙酸在类风湿性关节炎和骨关节炎患者管理中的相对有效性和耐受性的重要信息。接受联苯乙酸治疗的患者能够继续长期治疗的比例显著高于接受阿司匹林、吲哚美辛或安慰剂治疗的患者。这些试验结果表明,与阿司匹林或吲哚美辛相比,联苯乙酸的获益风险比更有利。