Scott L E, Clum G A
152 Henderson Hall, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Blacksburg, VA 24061 U.S.A.
Pain. 1984 Nov;20(3):279-291. doi: 10.1016/0304-3959(84)90017-4.
The present study sought to ameliorate two major deficiencies in the literature on treating response to surgery, viz., the failure to compare clearly delineated treatments, alone and in combination; and the failure to examine treatment X coping style interactions. Information imparting and brief relaxation were examined in this study as they interacted with an avoidance-sensitization coping style. No differences were found between treatments or coping styles. Sensitizers, on the other hand, were found to profit most from the relaxation training. Avoiders appeared to do well when they were left alone. The interaction effect was demonstrated for both self-report measures of pain and a behavioral measure of potency of medications ingested. The effects on self-report of pain were more evident on the second postsurgical day than on the fourth postsurgical day. The results indicate that brief relaxation training, often the only kind available to the medical psychologist dealing with surgical patients, is best confined to patients with a sensitizing coping style. Further, the results of this study, in conjunction with a reanalysis of previous studies, cast considerable doubt on information imparting when presented alone as a viable technique for reducing the distress consequent on surgery.
本研究试图改善手术治疗反应文献中的两个主要不足,即未能清晰比较单独及联合使用的明确界定的治疗方法;以及未能考察治疗与应对方式的相互作用。本研究考察了信息传递和简短放松,因为它们与回避 - 敏感应对方式相互作用。在治疗方法或应对方式之间未发现差异。另一方面,发现敏感者从放松训练中获益最大。回避者在不被打扰时似乎表现良好。疼痛的自我报告测量和摄入药物效力的行为测量均显示出交互作用。对疼痛自我报告的影响在术后第二天比在术后第四天更明显。结果表明,简短的放松训练(这通常是处理外科手术患者的医学心理学家唯一可用的方法)最适合具有敏感应对方式的患者。此外,本研究结果与对先前研究的重新分析一起,使人对单独将信息传递作为减轻手术所致痛苦的可行技术产生了相当大的怀疑。