Cummings B J, Hodson D I, Bush R S
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 1983 May;9(5):633-42. doi: 10.1016/0360-3016(83)90228-6.
Twenty-four patients with chordoma who received one or more courses of megavoltage radiation therapy following biopsy or incomplete resection were reviewed. The uncorrected survival rate at five years was 62%, and at 10 years was 28%, but most patients had clinically detectable residual chordoma present at the time of death or last follow-up. The duration of symptomatic improvement following irradiation ranged from a few months to 18 years, median 3.5 years. Detailed dose-time and symptomatic response data for 56 patients from this series and from the literature who were treated by conventional daily fractionated megavoltage irradiation show no convincing evidence that symptomatic relief is more likely after high doses than after total doses of only 4000 to 5500 cGy. Patients are rarely cured of chordoma by partial tumor resection and conventional radiation. Four patients received multiple fractions of 100 cGy each day either as retreatment for recurrence, or as initial treatment. Symptomatic responses, and decreases in the size of tumor masses, were seen following total doses ranging from 2000 cGy/20 fractions/5 days/4 X 3 hourly fractions each day to 4000 cGy/40 fractions/12 days/4 X 3 hourly fractions each day. The short duration of follow-up in these patients prevents comparison with conventional fractionation. However, this technique presents one possible new approach for the treatment of chordoma.
对24例脊索瘤患者进行了回顾性研究,这些患者在活检或不完全切除后接受了一个或多个疗程的兆伏级放射治疗。未经校正的5年生存率为62%,10年生存率为28%,但大多数患者在死亡或最后一次随访时临床上仍可检测到残留的脊索瘤。放疗后症状改善的持续时间从几个月到18年不等,中位数为3.5年。对该系列以及文献中56例接受常规每日分割兆伏级照射治疗的患者的详细剂量-时间和症状反应数据进行分析,未发现令人信服的证据表明高剂量照射后比仅4000至5500 cGy的总剂量照射后更有可能缓解症状。通过部分肿瘤切除和传统放疗很少能治愈脊索瘤患者。4例患者每天接受多次100 cGy的分割照射,作为复发性疾病的再治疗或初始治疗。在总剂量从2000 cGy/20次分割/5天/每天4次3小时分割到4000 cGy/40次分割/12天/每天4次3小时分割的情况下,观察到了症状反应和肿瘤肿块大小的减小。这些患者的随访时间较短,无法与传统分割照射进行比较。然而,这种技术为脊索瘤的治疗提供了一种可能的新方法。