Lichtenstein R L, Rykwalder A
Public Health Rep. 1983 Nov-Dec;98(6):589-96.
A profile of the personal and professional characteristics of the physicians who work in America's prisons was obtained by analyzing data from a larger study of all licensed physicians in the United States who worked in a prison at least 12 hours a month during the fall of 1979. Psychiatrists were not included, nor were physicians working in jails. The population of 382 prison physicians comprised two major groups--those who worked in prisons full time and those who worked in them part time. Part-time physicians, who represented the majority of physicians involved in prison work (58 percent), were found to resemble closely the typical physician in the United States; they were predominantly trained in America, specialized, and board certified. In contrast, full-time prison physicians, who accounted for 73 percent of the total hours physicians spent working in prisons, differed significantly from the typical U.S. physician. They were older, less specialized, less likely to be board certified, and more likely to be graduates of non-U.S. medical schools. The professional characteristics of the full-time prison physicians raise serious questions about the quality of medical care they are likely to provide. It would seem, based on their professional attributes, that the part-time physicians are able to provide better quality care than their full-time colleagues. Prison health system could thus assure higher quality care to inmates by relying primarily on part-time rather than full-time practitioners.
通过分析一项更大规模研究的数据,获取了在美国监狱工作的医生的个人和职业特征概况。该研究针对的是1979年秋季在美国所有获得执照且每月在监狱工作至少12小时的医生。研究未纳入精神科医生,也未包括在监狱工作的医生。382名监狱医生群体主要分为两大类——全职在监狱工作的医生和兼职在监狱工作的医生。兼职医生占参与监狱工作医生的大多数(58%),他们与美国典型医生极为相似;他们大多在美国接受培训,专业且获得了委员会认证。相比之下,全职监狱医生占医生在监狱工作总时长的73%,他们与美国典型医生有显著差异。他们年龄更大,专业性更弱,获得委员会认证的可能性更小,且更有可能毕业于非美国医学院校。全职监狱医生的职业特征引发了对他们可能提供的医疗服务质量的严重质疑。基于他们的职业属性来看,兼职医生似乎能够比全职同事提供更高质量的医疗服务。因此,监狱卫生系统主要依靠兼职而非全职医生,可能会为囚犯提供更高质量的医疗服务。