Olenick D L, Pear J J
J Appl Behav Anal. 1980 Spring;13(1):77-89. doi: 10.1901/jaba.1980.13-77.
A systematic sequence of prompt and probe trials was used to teach picture names to three severely retarded children. On prompt trials the experimenter presented a picture and said the picture name for the child to imitate; on probe trials the experimenter did not name the picture. A procedure whereby correct responses to prompts and probes were nondifferentially reinforced was compared with procedures whereby correct responses to prompts and probes were differentially reinforced according to separate and independent schedules of primary reinforcement. In Phase 1, correct responses to prompts and probes were reinforced nondifferentially on a fixed ratio (FR) 6 or 8 schedule; in Phase 2, correct responses to prompts were reinforced on the FR schedule and correct responses to probes were reinforced on an FR schedule of the same value; in Phase 3, correct responses to prompts were reinforced on the FR schedule and correct responses to probes were reinforced on a continuous reinforcement (CRF; every correct response reinforced) schedule; in Phase 4, correct responses to prompts were reinforced on a CRF schedule and correct responses to probes were reinforced on the FR schedule; in Phase 5, a reversal to the conditions of Phase 3 was conducted. For all three children, the FR schedule for correct responses to prompts combined with the CRF schedule for correct responses to probes (Phases 3 and 5) generated the highest number of correct responses to probes, the highest accuracy (correct responses relative to correct responses plus errors) on probe trials, and the highest rate of learning to name pictures.
采用一系列系统的提示和探测试验,向三名重度智力发育迟缓儿童教授图片名称。在提示试验中,实验者展示一张图片并说出图片名称,让儿童模仿;在探测试验中,实验者不说出图片名称。将对提示和探测的正确反应进行无差别强化的程序,与根据单独且独立的初级强化时间表对提示和探测的正确反应进行差别强化的程序进行了比较。在第1阶段,对提示和探测的正确反应按固定比率(FR)6或8的时间表进行无差别强化;在第2阶段,对提示的正确反应按FR时间表进行强化,对探测的正确反应按相同值的FR时间表进行强化;在第3阶段,对提示的正确反应按FR时间表进行强化,对探测的正确反应按连续强化(CRF;每次正确反应都强化)时间表进行强化;在第4阶段,对提示的正确反应按CRF时间表进行强化,对探测的正确反应按FR时间表进行强化;在第5阶段,恢复到第3阶段的条件。对于所有三名儿童,对提示的正确反应的FR时间表与对探测的正确反应的CRF时间表(第3阶段和第5阶段)相结合,产生了对探测的正确反应数量最多、探测试验中最高的准确率(正确反应相对于正确反应加错误)以及学习命名图片的最高速率。