Schwartz B
J Exp Psychol Gen. 1981 Sep;110(3):448-9.
Abramson and Alloy's reply to my comment suggests that we are in broad agreement. However, they suggest there is evidence that nondepressed people detect noncontingency accurately. That evidence seems weak at best. They also criticize me for faulting helplessness as being neither necessary nor sufficient for depression when it never actually claimed to be either. My concern was not with necessity or sufficiency, but with relevance.
艾布拉姆森和阿洛伊对我评论的回复表明我们大体上意见一致。然而,他们认为有证据表明非抑郁的人能准确察觉非关联性。但这证据充其量也很薄弱。他们还批评我指责无助感对抑郁而言既非必要条件也非充分条件,而无助感从未宣称自己是其中任何一个条件。我关注的不是必要性或充分性,而是相关性。