Sawyer J, Jeffries J J
J Clin Psychiatry. 1984 Sep;45(9):399-402.
In a study of 20 inpatients who met DSM-III criteria for schizophrenia, there was a high incidence of depressed mood (N = 14), DSM-III melancholia (N = 6) and dexamethasone nonsuppression (N = 7). This incidence of positive DSTs (serum cortisol greater than 5 micrograms/dl at 3:30 or 10:00) was significantly higher than the expected rate based on a literature review (35% vs. 4%, p less than .001). A positive DST did not result in all cases in antidepressant pharmacotherapy, nor did a negative result preclude such treatment. Hence, clinicians in the study did not "treat the DST" in the absence of clinical evidence of depression. This study is consistent with others reporting a significant proportion of depressed schizophrenics. However, some studies have claimed no differences in response to dexamethasone between nondepressed and schizophrenic patients. These findings do not support a biological basis for the RDC differentiation of primary and secondary depression and challenge the DSM-III concept of schizophrenia as excluding the diagnosis of major depression. Viewed from a different perspective, the data may support recent reports casting doubt on the specificity of the DST.
在一项针对20名符合精神分裂症DSM - III标准的住院患者的研究中,出现抑郁情绪(N = 14)、DSM - III型忧郁症(N = 6)和地塞米松抑制试验阴性(N = 7)的发生率很高。地塞米松抑制试验阳性(下午3:30或上午10:00时血清皮质醇大于5微克/分升)的发生率显著高于基于文献综述预期的发生率(35%对4%,p小于0.001)。地塞米松抑制试验阳性并非在所有病例中都导致抗抑郁药物治疗,阴性结果也不排除这种治疗。因此,该研究中的临床医生在没有抑郁临床证据的情况下并未“根据地塞米松抑制试验结果进行治疗”。这项研究与其他报告大量抑郁性精神分裂症患者的研究一致。然而,一些研究称非抑郁患者和精神分裂症患者对地塞米松的反应没有差异。这些发现不支持原发性和继发性抑郁的研究诊断标准委员会(RDC)区分的生物学基础,并对DSM - III中精神分裂症排除重度抑郁诊断的概念提出了挑战。从不同角度看,这些数据可能支持最近对地塞米松抑制试验特异性提出质疑的报告。