Watson C G
J Clin Psychol. 1984 Jul;40(4):1008-23. doi: 10.1002/1097-4679(198407)40:4<1008::aid-jclp2270400425>3.0.co;2-9.
Reviewed the research on the MMPI Schizophrenia-Organicity (Sc-O) and Psychiatric-Organic (P-O) Scales, measures developed to separate brain-damaged patients from schizophrenics and from functional psychiatric patients as a whole. Over 10 cross-validations, the average Sc-O scale hit rate has been 69%, which suggests that it is a better differentiator of brain-damaged from schizophrenic males than most popular ability-based organicity tests. Hit rates for five studies that contrasted organic and psychiatric patients on the P-O scale also averaged 69%. The scales appear to be useful in both medical and psychiatric hospitals, but their validities in female samples are not well established. A system for making diagnostic decisions from ability and personality measures in combination is described, and evidence is cited that it improves on the hit rates achieved by either type of test alone.
回顾了明尼苏达多相人格测验(MMPI)中精神分裂症-器质性(Sc-O)量表和精神疾病-器质性(P-O)量表的相关研究,这两个量表旨在将脑损伤患者与精神分裂症患者以及整体功能性精神疾病患者区分开来。在超过10次交叉验证中,Sc-O量表的平均命中率为69%,这表明与大多数流行的基于能力的器质性测试相比,它在区分脑损伤男性和精神分裂症男性方面表现更佳。五项在P-O量表上对比器质性患者和精神疾病患者的研究的命中率平均也为69%。这些量表在综合医院和精神病院似乎都有用,但它们在女性样本中的效度尚未得到充分证实。文中描述了一种结合能力和人格测量进行诊断决策的系统,并引用证据表明该系统比单独使用任何一种测试所达到的命中率都有所提高。