Krauland W
Arch Kriminol. 1984 Jul-Aug;174(1-2):1-22.
The evidential value of the finding "gun in the hand" has been rated differently in the course of time. While Casper (1857) considered it to be infallible proof of suicide, investigators in later years tended to see it more as a manipulation for the purpose of faking a suicide. In 71 cases of proven suicide by a shot in the head on which autopsies were performed by the Institute of Forensic Medicine (1956-1983), 20 (= 28%) were found with the gun in their hands according to police reports. No case was reported in which the gun was placed in the hand after the fact. The problem is discussed from various points of view (decerebrate rigidity, cataleptic rigidity, multiple shots, capacity to act). In the literature, on the other hand, there were 3 cases in which a gun was placed in the hand of a dead person to provide substantiation of a suicide; three more cases were found in a poll.
“手中持枪”这一发现的证据价值在不同时期有着不同的评定。虽然卡斯珀(1857年)认为这是自杀的确凿证据,但后来的调查人员更倾向于将其视为为伪造自杀而进行的一种手段。在法医研究所(1956 - 1983年)进行尸检的71例经证实的头部枪击自杀案例中,根据警方报告,有20例(占28%)死者手中持有枪支。没有报告显示枪支是在事后被放入手中的。从多个角度(去大脑强直、僵住症、多次枪击、行动能力)对这一问题进行了讨论。另一方面,文献中有3例是将枪放在死者手中以证实自杀;在一项调查中还发现了另外3例。