Kolvin I, Berney T P, Bhate S R
Br J Psychiatry. 1984 Oct;145:347-57. doi: 10.1192/bjp.145.4.347.
Fifty-one school phobic children, aged nine to fourteen years, were assessed for psychiatric diagnosis; this revealed the presence of two clinically meaningful sub-groups--depressed and residual school phobic. A wide range of symptoms were studied to identify those which might prove useful in diagnosing adult-type depression in childhood and early adolescence, both in terms of frequency of symptoms in the depressed group and the extent of the distinction between the two groups. Eleven such key symptoms were identified and based on these, a formula for diagnosing adult-type depression was evolved. The validity of several different ways of classifying the above cases were explored; these covered: kind of disorder; type of onset; adolescence versus pre-adolescence; and sex of the child. However, on only one dichotomy--depression versus absence of depression--were there many significant discriminants. Affective symptomatology of more recent onset was contrasted with pre-morbid personality traits, usually associated with school phobia. There was no evidence to support the concept of 'masked depression' in childhood.
对51名年龄在9至14岁的学校恐惧症儿童进行了精神疾病诊断评估;结果显示存在两个具有临床意义的亚组——抑郁型和残留型学校恐惧症。研究了一系列症状,以确定那些在诊断儿童期和青春期早期成人型抑郁症方面可能有用的症状,包括抑郁组症状出现的频率以及两组之间的差异程度。确定了11个这样的关键症状,并在此基础上形成了一个诊断成人型抑郁症的公式。探讨了对上述病例进行几种不同分类方式的有效性;这些分类包括:疾病类型;发病类型;青春期与青春期前;以及儿童性别。然而,只有在一个二分法——抑郁与非抑郁——上存在许多显著的判别因素。将近期发病的情感症状与通常与学校恐惧症相关的病前人格特征进行了对比。没有证据支持儿童期“隐匿性抑郁症”的概念。