Kaiser M K, Proffitt D R
Child Dev. 1984 Aug;55(4):1614-24.
The present study examined whether younger observers (kindergartners, second graders, and fourth graders) could extract relative weight information from collisions and also lifting events, and if they could judge whether collisions were natural (i.e., momentum conserving) or anomalous (non-momentum conserving). 20 children at each age and 20 adults viewed videotapes of 8 collisions (4 natural, 4 anomalous) and 6 sequences of lifting events. Observers also viewed sequences of static images taken from these events. Observers at all grade levels were able to reliably judge relative weight in both collisions and lifting events, and could differentiate between natural and anomalous collisions. Performance was much poorer when static sequences of the events were viewed, especially for the young children. A consistent age trend was noted across tasks: adults performed better than second and fourth graders who, in turn, performed better than kindergartners. In addition, there was evidence that younger children were differentially aided when the kinematics of the event made the kinetics more pronounced.
本研究考察了较年轻的观察者(幼儿园儿童、二年级学生和四年级学生)是否能够从碰撞以及提起事件中提取相对重量信息,以及他们是否能够判断碰撞是自然的(即动量守恒)还是异常的(非动量守恒)。每个年龄段有20名儿童和20名成年人观看了8次碰撞(4次自然碰撞、4次异常碰撞)以及6组提起事件的录像带。观察者还观看了从这些事件中截取的静态图像序列。所有年级的观察者都能够可靠地判断碰撞和提起事件中的相对重量,并能够区分自然碰撞和异常碰撞。当观看事件的静态序列时,表现要差得多,尤其是对幼儿而言。在各项任务中都观察到了一致的年龄趋势:成年人的表现优于二年级和四年级学生,而二年级和四年级学生又比幼儿园儿童表现得更好。此外,有证据表明,当事件的运动学使动力学更加明显时,年幼儿童会得到不同程度的帮助。