Liddell F D, Thomas D C, Gibbs G W, McDonald J C
Ann Acad Med Singap. 1984 Apr;13(2 Suppl):340-4.
To define the relationships between chrysotile exposure in fibre terms and death from specific cancers, and pneumoconiosis, all 11,379 persons born 1891-1920 who had worked in the asbestos mines and mills of Quebec for a month or more before 1967 were followed to the end of 1975. Among the 10,939 men, there had been 4,463 deaths, 634 from these causes. For each death, referents were randomly selected from among men in the cohort born in the same year as the case and known to have survived to a greater age. For each case and his referents, exposures accumulated up to nine years before the death of the case had been obtained as (million particles per cubic foot) x years. Fibre counts were estimated for each work-place so that all exposures could be expressed in (fibres/ml) x years. The ratio of the means for all 2,586 accumulated exposures was 3.46 (f/ml)/mpcf. Relative Risks (RR) were related to exposure by matched analysis. For pneumoconiosis and lung cancer, RR = 1 + b.(f/ml).y fitted well, with b estimated as 0.00647 and 0.00038, respectively. For cancers of upper and of lower G.I. tract, severe exposure was associated with elevated RRs, but rather unclearly. For other abdominal cancers, and laryngeal cancer, risks and exposure were not positively associated. The asbestos-smoking interaction in lung cancer was closer to multiplicative than to additive.
为了确定温石棉纤维暴露与特定癌症死亡以及尘肺病之间的关系,对1967年以前在魁北克石棉矿和工厂工作过一个月或更长时间、出生于1891年至1920年的所有11379人进行了随访,直至1975年底。在这10939名男性中,有4463人死亡,其中634人死于上述原因。对于每一例死亡,从与病例同年出生且已知存活至更高年龄的队列男性中随机选择对照。对于每一例病例及其对照,已获取病例死亡前累计达九年的暴露量,单位为(每立方英尺百万颗粒数)×年。对每个工作场所的纤维计数进行了估算,以便所有暴露量都可以用(纤维/毫升)×年表示。所有2586次累计暴露量的均值之比为3.46(纤维/毫升)/(每立方英尺百万颗粒数)。通过匹配分析将相对风险(RR)与暴露量相关联。对于尘肺病和肺癌,RR = 1 + b·(纤维/毫升)·y拟合良好,b分别估计为0.00647和0.00038。对于上消化道和下消化道癌症,高暴露与RR升高相关,但关系不太明确。对于其他腹部癌症和喉癌,风险与暴露量没有正相关关系。肺癌中的石棉与吸烟的相互作用更接近相乘而非相加。