Wunderlich R A, Lozes J
Psychiatr Q. 1984 Summer;56(2):144-50. doi: 10.1007/BF01064950.
While juvenile delinquents (JDs) and status offenders (CINS) are considered distinctive legally and treated as though they were different in the juvenile justice system, there is little empirical evidence to support either differences or similarities psychologically. The present study examines intake and outcome data based on 96 JDs and CINS cases who remained in the community. The two groups' family structure, recidivism, and grade termination in school were found to be more similar than dissimilar. However, there was a tendency toward a more negative relationship between CINS and their mothers than between JDs and their mothers, while relationships with fathers were similar for the two groups. Significant, and perhaps related, findings were that more parents of CINS than JDs had previously been involved in psychotherapy and that CINS were removed from home with greater frequency than JDs. Family structure was found to be related to removal from home. Suggestions for treatment are offered.
虽然青少年犯罪者(JDs)和身份犯罪者(CINS)在法律上被视为不同,并在少年司法系统中被区别对待,但几乎没有实证证据支持他们在心理上存在差异或相似之处。本研究基于96例仍留在社区中的青少年犯罪者和身份犯罪者的案例,对其收容和结果数据进行了考察。结果发现,两组在家庭结构、再犯情况和学业结束情况方面的相似之处多于不同之处。然而,身份犯罪者与其母亲之间的关系比青少年犯罪者与其母亲之间的关系更倾向于负面,而两组与父亲的关系则相似。重要且可能相关的发现是,身份犯罪者的父母比青少年犯罪者的父母此前更多地参与过心理治疗,而且身份犯罪者被带离家庭的频率高于青少年犯罪者。研究发现家庭结构与被带离家庭有关。文中还提供了治疗建议。