Kumar A, Durai V, Sirumban P
Indian J Lepr. 1984 Jul-Sep;56(3):626-32.
The diagnostic efficiency and accuracy in classification of leprosy and its activity status, by four senior trained Paramedical Workers (PMWs) involved in leprosy case detection programme, was assessed on 1394 cases detected by them and concurrently confirmed by an experienced medical officer. The inter-observer variation between two experienced PMWs in diagnosis and classification of leprosy on 216 patients, was also studied. Of the 1394 cases detected by PMWs, 257 (18.44%) were wrongly diagnosed as leprosy, mostly as non-lepromatous (N) type. Though all lepromatous (L) and 98% of N-type cases were correctly classified by PMWs, 25.64% of borderline (N ? L) cases were either under-diagnosed as N-type (17.95%) or over-diagnosed as L-type (7.69%). The activity status of 19% cases was wrongly assessed by PMWs, including 8% active lesions assessed as inactive. The discrepancy between two PMWs in diagnosis, classification and assessment of activity status of leprosy was found in 1.39%, 7.41% & 25.67% cases, respectively. The implications of these observations, and the suggestions to improve the technical skills of workers for an efficient and effective implementation of leprosy control programme, are discussed in this communication.
对参与麻风病病例检测项目的4名资深培训过的辅助医务人员(PMW),就其对1394例由他们检测并同时经一名经验丰富的医务人员确诊的麻风病病例进行分类的诊断效率和准确性进行了评估。还研究了两名经验丰富的PMW对216例患者麻风病诊断和分类的观察者间差异。在PMW检测的1394例病例中,257例(18.44%)被误诊为麻风病,大多被误诊为非瘤型(N)。虽然所有瘤型(L)和98%的N型病例被PMW正确分类,但25.64%的界线类(N?L)病例要么被漏诊为N型(17.95%),要么被误诊为L型(7.69%)。PMW对19%病例的活动状态评估错误,包括8%有活动性损害的病例被评估为无活动性。两名PMW在麻风病诊断、分类和活动状态评估方面的差异分别在1.39%、7.41%和25.67%的病例中被发现。本文讨论了这些观察结果的意义,以及为有效实施麻风病控制项目提高工作人员技术技能的建议。