Böcking A
Microsc Acta Suppl. 1983;6:91-102.
The different validity of DNA-cytophotometric parameters to morphometric ones for the automated cytological diagnosis of cancer is discussed and demonstrated for prostatic-, cervical- and lymph-node cytology by own measurements. Nuclear-DNA-cytophotometry used for the automation of cytological diagnosis of malignancy has the following advantages compared to image analysis: 1) DNA-cytophotometry mostly yields more sensitive parameters for the diagnosis of malignancy than image analysis does and thus results in greater diagnostic accuracy. 2) Cytological diagnosis of malignancy may often be possible in earlier stages of the tumor-history with nuclear-DNA-parameters compared to morphological parameters. 3) The prognostic validity of nuclear-DNA-distribution is probably greater than of cytomorphological parameters. 4) The parameters of nuclear-DNA-distribution for cytodiagnosis and grading of malignancy are the same for most of the human tumors in contrast to morphological parameters which are different for histogenetically different tumor. 5) Processing time for the automated diagnostic procedure of the slides will be much shorter if the Feulgen-stain for DNA is used instead of the Papanicolaou-stain for image analysis. One disadvantage of nuclear DNA-measurements as a diagnostic toll is the fact that cytopathologists cannot fully control the diagnostic process and results with their own eyes in Feulgen-stained slides. Meanwhile, however, even in other medical disciplines diagnosis are made by objective measurements of parameters which are not discernible by the human eye. That diagnostic procedure has to be accepted which yields the most accurate and reproducible diagnosis in the shortest time. It is recommended to combine cytomorphological and DNA-cytophotometric parameters as diagnostic tools for automated cytodiagnosis in Feulgen-stained slides.
通过自身测量,讨论并展示了DNA细胞光度测量参数与形态测量参数在前列腺、宫颈和淋巴结细胞学癌症自动诊断中的不同有效性。与图像分析相比,用于恶性肿瘤细胞学诊断自动化的核DNA细胞光度测量具有以下优点:1)DNA细胞光度测量在恶性肿瘤诊断中产生的参数大多比图像分析更敏感,因此诊断准确性更高。2)与形态学参数相比,利用核DNA参数在肿瘤发展的早期阶段通常就可以进行恶性肿瘤的细胞学诊断。3)核DNA分布的预后有效性可能大于细胞形态学参数。4)与形态学参数不同,不同组织发生的肿瘤其形态学参数不同,而大多数人类肿瘤的用于细胞诊断和恶性肿瘤分级的核DNA分布参数是相同的。5)如果使用DNA的福尔根染色而不是用于图像分析的巴氏染色,玻片自动诊断程序的处理时间将大大缩短。核DNA测量作为一种诊断工具的一个缺点是,细胞病理学家无法通过肉眼完全控制福尔根染色玻片中的诊断过程和结果。然而,与此同时,即使在其他医学学科中,诊断也是通过对人眼无法辨别的参数进行客观测量来进行的。必须接受那种能在最短时间内提供最准确和可重复诊断的诊断程序。建议将细胞形态学和DNA细胞光度测量参数结合起来,作为福尔根染色玻片中自动细胞诊断的诊断工具。